Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Varieties of Counterinsurgency Strategies in Late Nineteenth Century East Asia

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The second half of the nineteenth century saw a rapid proliferation of political violence – by both state and nonstate actors – in the East Asian region. Existing accounts point to the regional shift in the military balance of power, usually attributed to factors such as the declining influence of Qing China, the gunboat diplomacy of Western powers, and a revisionist and militarizing Japan led by a new revolutionary government, as the primary cause of increasing militarization of political crises during this period. In doing so, the focus tends to be placed on successive interstate wars (such as the Sino-Japanese War of 1894-95 and Russo-Japanese War of 1904-05) that highlight heightened military competition and imperialist expansion. While certainly a crucial aspect of East Asian international relations at this time, we have less of an understanding of the impact of the Boshin War (1868-69) in Japan, the Taiping, Nian, and Muslim rebellions (1850s-1870s) in China, and the Jinju, Imo, and Tonkhak rebellions in Korea.

In this paper, I shift the attention to the varied matrix of internal security threats in nineteenth century East Asia and how the timing and type of these prior experiences with domestic political violence shaped the state’s ability to respond to future security threats from both outside and within. I argue that East Asian states’ responses to security threats, and their strategies involving political violence, were heavily influenced by their prior experience with internal security threats. In doing so, I challenge the view that external pressures and security threats were the primary triggers for political and military reforms in East Asia, with varying degrees of success. Specifically, I show how Meiji Japan, Qing China, and Chosŏn Korea each faced significant domestic security threats – in the form of insurgencies, rebellions, and civil war – in the second half of the nineteenth century. Each regime responded with distinct strategies of counterinsurgency, ranging from state-led centralization of coercive institutions (including the military and police) to the creation of decentralized but force-multiplying regional militias to reliance on foreign aid.

Author