Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

From Tinkering to Hacking and the Rise of Neoliberalism

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper takes up the question of complexity in production and how perhaps the machine process might be overcome through social evolution. It does so by thinking through the difference between “tinkering” and “hacking.” Tinkering culture emerged relatively early in industrial production, as consumers of products deduced how machine-made goods were built, and in so doing might improve or fabricate their own designs in a kind of reverse-engineered handicraft. Tinkering, essentially, is an attempt to unlock the machine process and make the steps by which commodities are produced visible. In so doing, tinkerers could ostensibly mimic the machine process in a bespoke fashion; indeed, people would build their own cars, which is unthinkable now. The complexity makes that a functional impossibility. By contrast, a later emerging culture of hacking is not concerned with producing an item start to finish, but instead reproducing networked logic to chart, dispute, or disrupt organizational systems. In the shift from tinkering to hacking, there is a germ of a neoliberal rationality of individuals who operate on their own, perpendicular to the mode of production in which they otherwise operate, and in which they are fully responsible for all behaviors and outcomes.

This narrowly scoped survey of American political history shows a general inward-turning that is a hallmark of neoliberal rationality; from a preparedness to defend nature from the unknown other, to disdaining the dirtiness of industrial production by opting out for handicraft, to the hermetically sealed family bunkers of the Cold War, to the rise of tinkering and hacking as a way to end-run the system for individual benefit. Over and over the theme emerges that individuals have to figure things out for themselves and that nobody will be coming to help them, least of all a functional state. This paper again brings in Thorstein Veblen and his theory of the Soviet of Engineers; a system of production that is just as - if not more - complex than the current mode of industrial production. In Veblen’s formulation, the soviet is not built on everybody knowing how to build all the means of life from start to finish, but rather having a knowledge of the mode of production itself. This is what Veblen means when he refers to engineers. This paper ends with a vision of what a democratic and collective response might look like that does not eschew the mode of production, but rather works through it for democratic and peaceable ends and the prospects of such a soviet of engineers in the current context.

Author