Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Why Do Migrants Take Recourse in the European Court of Human Rights?

Fri, October 1, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Since the 1990s, the European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has become a prominent transnational venue where central issues regarding migrants’ protection and states’ border control are raised and adjudicated. Why have migrants and asylum seekers taken recourse to the ECtHR in increasing numbers? Who are the actors involved in the relevant complaints, which countries do these most frequently target, and what issues do they raise? In exploring these questions, the proposed paper draws from existing theories about the causes of litigation and legal mobilization that highlight the role of international legal opportunities, domestic legal and political constraints, and the role of civil society actors. The empirical analysis is based on aggregate data generated from a case law data set of over 450 relevant decisions and judgments issued by the ECtHR. The paper argues that the growth in migrant-related human rights claims has been a path-dependent process. While international legal opportunities are crucial in opening up space for individual complaints, such opportunities have largely been the result of legal action and social mobilization by lawyers and civil society organizations in the first place. To be sure, non-governmental organizations of various kinds are involved in a relatively small number of migrant-related human rights complaints. Instead, the bulk of litigation has been driven by the active engagement of individual practicing lawyers providing support and legal representation to non-nationals. Nonetheless, human rights cases and Court judgments, in which NGOs are involved, whether supporting applicants or acting as Third-Party Interveners, are far more likely to influence evolving human rights caselaw and states’ law and policy in the area of immigration and asylum.

Author