Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

Problems of Plural Societies: Debates in the Political Economy of Decolonization

Sun, October 3, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper reconstructs the social theory of the plural society in Anglophone development economics and comparative politics in order to excavate the influence of anxieties about the symptoms of late colonial capitalism on the form of the postcolonial developmental state. Development in general, and developmental historicism in particular, has long been identified as a critical locus of imperial domination. Now-canonical studies of nineteenth century imperial liberalism (Mehta 2001, Pitts 2003), for example, identify ideologies of civilizational deficit as a source of justification for imperial rule, while more recent studies of anticolonial political thought show how contestation of the supposed underdevelopment of colonized societies qua political communities shaped the strategies and tactics of anticolonial political action (Sultan 2020). Accordingly, assessments of contemporary developmentalism as a site of political unfreedom often locates its harms in its constitution of subject populations as sites of lack or abnormal divergence from a trajectory of normative social and political evolution (Escobar 1995).

This paper reorients our understanding of the relationship between developmentalism and unfreedom by focusing on the articulation of development as a state form in the mid-twentieth century, especially although not exclusively in the constitution of postcolonial regimes as developmental states. It does so by reconstructing a crucial political conjuncture within which the theoretic categories of the mid-twentieth century developmentalism were forged, namely, the rejuvenation of the field of comparative colonial administration by the interwar crises of the British Empire.

The paper begins by highlighting the traces of the dilemmas of the plural society as they pervade the political thought of an unlikely pair of exemplary figures: the American economic historian and modernization theorist, W.W. Rostow, and the Saint Lucian political economist and sometimes pan-Africanist, W. Arthur Lewis. More specifically, I track how these founding figures in comparative politics and development economics characterized the objects of their study—which expand to include not only the “new states” of Africa and Asia, but also what we might now describe as the Third World—as communities riven by racial, ethnic, caste, and religious difference (the “plural society”), exacerbated by the uneven diffusion of capitalist and pre-capitalist social forms (the “dual economy”). I then elucidate the politics of the dual economy/plural society genealogically and comparatively: by locating its origins in the interwar reworking, within the Fabian Colonial Bureau and its allies in the emergent discipline of social anthropology, of the trope of the transition from status to contract in the social theory of Henry Sumner Maine (Mantena 2011; Foks 2018), and by contrasting its problematics with those of contemporaneous structuralist approaches to political economy, chiefly the formations of post-Ranadian Indian economics and the first wave of dependency theories being articulated in the work of Raul Prebisch, Celso Furtado, and other members of the Economic Commission for Latin America.

I conclude by considering how the recovery of the sociological theory of the plural society, especially the framing of problems of postcolonial institutional and constitutional design through its lens illuminates underexplored continuities between the late colonial politics of trusteeship and the politics of postcolonial developmental states. The recovery of a central social theoretic frame of twentieth century developmentalism, I contend, offers a critical vantage point from which to assess the legacies of the fraught negotiation of the twin imperatives of stability maintenance and social transformation in an enduring postcolonial present (Scott 2004).

Author