Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Role of Prior Experience in Responses to Pandemic Threats

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The politics of public health in the United States is a pluralist admixture of the local, the state, and the national. Public policy discussions often emphasize the need for trust in public health and recognize the value of gathering data and promoting intervention in responding to public health threats. The police power may also be invoked in times of crisis. Not to
dismiss or to diminish the weight assigned to trust or the police power, however, we examine in this paper the hypothesis that sustained exposure to health threats and harm recurrence have value in responding successfully to pandemic threats. To take potentially analogous policy area, the severity and frequency of earthquakes in Chile, California, Alaska, and Japan have generated sophisticated building codes designed to reduce loss of life. In sharp contrast, the eastern half of the United States has not adopted building codes similar to the west coast states though prediction suggest that eastern states do also in the long run face the risk of a major earthquake.
Neither the United States nor European countries have had significant direct experience of pandemic threats for just over 100 years. At the outset of the COVID-19 pandemic, the United States was underprepared for a major health event, let alone a pandemic of great proportions and it remained so for months. Public concern was for the most part either modest or dismissive. But as the year progressed over its first full year and into the second, attitudes began to shift. Public recognition has strengthened that the threat is serious and needs to be addressed by both individual action and political authority. This substantive shift, we hypothesize, is not related to trust in the government but in a commitment to adjust how one lives and what one should expect from public authorities. In short, there have been shifts in personal and public expectations that may deepen and endure the longer the pandemic is perceived as a threat.
Our analysis will draw on two major sources. First, we will use survey data from organizations such the Covid States Project and the Pew Research Center to assess changes in attitudes toward government, public health, and COVID response policies over the course of the pandemic. Second, we are gathering data in selected states about the extent of influenza pandemic planning in 2009, state budgetary appropriations for pandemic planning over the years between 2009 and 2019, state budgetary appropriations since 2019 for immediate actions to address the pandemic such as testing or vaccine delivery, and any state appropriations for continuing state public health infrastructure. We hypothesize that changes in appropriations of pandemic related costs to health departments and other related agencies may not correlate with the red or blue partisan orientation of the state but instead with changes in public attitudes towards the need for effective public health efforts that are rooted in experience of responses to the emergency over time.

Authors