Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Download

A Redefined Indian-ness and the Decline of India’s Democracy

Sun, October 3, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

India’s democracy has entered a new era of decline. Twenty years ago, India’s democracy was low-quality but robust, and a beacon of hope around the world that democracy could grow roots in such diverse and poor soil. Two decades later, the state of India’s democracy is no longer a beacon of hope. I argue that a changing national identity has critically driven India’s democratic decline. Ancient philosophers and contemporary political scientists alike have suggested that a broadly shared political culture matters for any form of effective government. For any society to pursue its common good first requires a basic understanding of what is common – or an articulation of basic values from which political debate over how best to realize these values ensues. Political culture usually denotes beliefs, attitudes, and values for a delimited political community. But while beliefs and attitudes can change in relatively short periods of time in response to the demographic changes accompanying economic modernization, dominant national narratives are typically forged at foundational moments, are sticky, and rarely fundamentally shift. Yet India has witnessed just such a fundamental transformation in its national narrative over the past decade. A dominant e pluribus unum conception of India, rhetorically embracing linguistic and religious diversity since the country’s founding, has been palpably transformed into one dominantly defined by Hinduism. Despite an array of political leaders and scholars alike who have decried the contemporary rise of nationalism as deleterious for democracy, there has been little clarity as to whether, how and why nationalism impacts democracy. The central task of this paper is to empirically summarize the changes in India’s national identity and to unpack the causal logic of why a national narrative dominantly defined by an immutable identity such as ethnicity, race or religion has direct and debilitating consequences for democracy.

Author