Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Gendered Inclusion: Estimating the Gender Gap in Turnout in Latin America

Wed, September 29, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

The origins and trajectories of democracy and authoritarianism are among the most central and analyzed issues in comparative politics. The literature covers all regions, methodological traditions, and theoretical approaches. Women, however, have not been incorporated into mainstream studies of democratization, particularly when focusing on the historical origins of regimes. Although a feminist scholarship has emerged to tackle these exclusions, the conceptual and theoretical consequences of incorporating gender into democratization studies remain underexplored (Caraway, 2004). Recent scholarship is starting to tackle the issue, using new techniques, data, and research designs (e.g. Kim 2019; Morgan-Collins Forthcoming). However, political science research has paid little attention to women’s early political inclusion and participation outside the US and Western Europe. The evolution of the gender gap indicates that women’s initial participation after enfranchisement was relatively low, that it eventually equalized with that of men, and that in recent decades there is even a slightly higher rate of turnout among women (Carreras & Castañeda, 2014; Corder & Wolbrecht, 2016; Lewis, 2004). However, specific variations across time and space remain unknown. For Latin America, at present we do not know how countries varied in the sequence of achieving actual equal participation in voting and real inclusion in the polity.
The central argument of this paper is that while women’s suffrage was a fundamental milestone, other formal and informal institutions also had a gendered effect in electoral political participation, making rates of women’s incorporation variable across countries. In particular, I consider the conditions for suffrage (i.e. literacy requirement, registration procedures, mandatory or voluntary vote), socio-demographic variables such as differences between men and women in education levels, and competitiveness of elections as factors that potentially impact the gender gap in participation. To evaluate these claims, and following up updated version of Corder and Wolbrecht’s approach (2016, pp. 103–125), I estimate turnout rates by gender in presidential elections in Brazil, Chile, Colombia, Costa Rica, and Peru for the post-women’s enfranchisement period. These cases cover important geographical, cultural, ethnic, institutional, and political variation present in Latin America. With these estimates I reconstruct the sequences of women’s participation, considering the moment of enfranchisement until the beginning of the third wave of democratization. I analyze variations by country in how the rates of women’s inclusion into the electoral arena evolved in time as well as spikes in participation. Using qualitative comparative analysis (QCA), I then assess how the institutional, socio-demographic, and political variables mentioned above relate to variations across countries in the gendered nature of political participation.
This paper makes important empirical and analytical contributions to our understanding of the inclusion dimension of democratization. Empirically, extant research on political participation has focused in the period following the last wave of democratic transitions, adopted a synchronic instead of diachronic view, and even fully ignored a gender gap in turnout given lack of data (Carreras & Castañeda, 2014; Desposato & Norrander, 2009; Fornos, Power, & Garand, 2004). Because existing work has not asked questions about women and democratization in Latin America, we know very little factually about the topic. Collecting electoral data and estimating turnout rates is an important effort in this direction. Analytically, this work problematizes approaches that consider women’s enfranchisement as the final step in their democratic inclusion and overlook how participation remained gendered for several more decades. Moreover, it offers a cross-country comparison that has been absent in the recent literature. By analyzing how women were affected by, for example, literacy requirements to a higher degree than men, this work introduces new milestones and sequences of inclusion that will necessarily complicate and enrich existing theories of the process of democratization. New actors, new conflicts, and new causal forces will emerge in the explanation of these new episodes. Finally, by studying women’s political inclusion, my research seeks to correct three biases within mainstream democratization literature: the male democracy bias, the class bias, and the European bias (e.g. Ansell & Samuels, 2014; Boix, 2003; Collier, 1999; Moore, 1966; Rueschemeyer, Stephens, & Stephens, 1992; Ziblatt, 2017).

Author