Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Ethnic diversity is a common feature of many societies. In the context of increasingly visible diversity individual states have to decide whether to disregard or acknowledge such diversity, which groups to single out and protect, and how. Collective ethnic rights provide a good framework to systematically examine modes of protection and empowerment of ethnic diversity. The literature distinguishes between ethnic quotas securing minority political voice and representation, decentralization along ethnic lines allowing ethnic self-government, and collective rights in the cultural domain, protecting ethno-cultural distinctiveness (which are especially visible for immigrant minorities). Nevertheless, the final effect of protection and empowerment of ethnic difference is unclear. On the one side, scholars point that protection of minorities is a necessary part of liberal democracy, and that empowered groups are better integrated and exhibit higher level of trust in political institutions. On the opposite side, sceptics warn of the threat of escalating ethnic demands, disengagement from the society and politics at large, or even ethnic confrontation. The systematic assessment of the effects of ethnic empowerment through collective ethnic rights in different contexts is still missing.
This paper proposes a new approach to evaluate the effects of ethnic empowerment across countries, looking at examples from Europe. I recognize the complexity of ethnic empowerment and the need to account for level of politicization of ethnic cleavage, and presence/absence of different types of collective ethnic rights. I develop a framework that examines the effects of collective ethnic rights in the political arena and in society at large. In particular, I focus on identifying actors with vested interest in the domain of ethnic politics, and examine how they influence the perception of success or failure of ethnic empowerment.
Empirically, I use inductive approach based on semi-structured interviews with elite actors from political parties, civil society, state institutions, and experts on ethnic politics. I aim to understand how ethnic empowerment and ethnic issues broadly defined are perceived and framed. To account for cross-country variation in degree of salience of ethnic issues, I examine countries with widely different ethnic cleavages and centrality of ethnic politics: Bosnia and Herzegovina, North Macedonia, Bulgaria, and Sweden.
I find that across the countries framing of ethnic empowerment markedly differs between political and societal spheres. Overall, actors in the political sphere tend to frame ethnic issues in more contentious terms, especially when they may benefit from higher visibility of ethnic issues and ethnic empowerment. Opposite to them, the actors working outside of formal politics better identify less-visible interethnic success stories, shared interests, and problems that cross ethnic boundaries.
The analysis points at the limitations of models of ethnic empowerment that focus on institutional solutions and elites in the political sphere. Instead, informal interethnic contact among ethnically diverse population appears to be one of the key challenges, which has the biggest potential for minimizing ethnic polarization and achieving better interethnic relations. Methodologically, my work underlines the importance of inductive approach and qualitative work in the domain of ethnic politics, applied cross-nationally.