Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
The earth, many claim, may be witnessing the sixth great mass extinction of plants and animals—every year 10,000 to 100,000 species disappear—and increasingly, people suspect that they too may be in that number. Dozens die out every single day. Not only do we live in the midst of destruction and disappearance, we also live with an increased awareness of our future demise as a species (eventually unavoidable), and, furthermore, an awareness of our active role in this destruction. Catastrophic conclusions structure our policies, fantasies, and philosophies. How do we live in such desperate times? How does one respond to threats of overwhelming destruction in a manner that affirms life and nurtures political possibilities for the future?
Some people turn to nostalgia and denial in response to evidence of destruction; some even adopt a will to self-destruction or miraculous escape. Among white evangelical Protestants 77% believe that the changes in the earth foreshadow the return of the messiah and the end of time. In this essay I turn to one of the sources of that messianic escape plan, Paul of Tarsus. No one has been more influential for our conceptions of the end of time than Paul. His supposed claims about how the Parousia holds back the end of the world have taken on various permutations over the centuries, including the apocalyptic orientation of American evangelicals. Paul’s letters, I argue, are a richer resource than that, and they provide useful reflections for the rest of us living and dying at the ending of a world.
Three elements in particular, suggest possibilities that might help us respond to the current planetary crisis. First, Paul’s careful attention to orientation. Writing about Paul’s letter to the Galatians, Heidegger pointed out that “conducting … life,” particularly, the “posture of life to which I am turned” is a formulation “characteristic of Paul.” Paul’s attention to deportment and orientation offers possibilities for those of us living at the end of the world. “Paul is not concerned at all about answering the question of the When of the Parousia,” wrote Heidegger. After all, “the When is determined through the How of the self-comportment, which is determined through the enactment of factical life experience in each of its moments” (Heidegger).
Second, Paul’s world is bigger than people. The world involved a living planet, including plants, animals, (and if Luke can be trusted) even the rocks. Third, in a claim that caused a lot of confusion for his earliest followers, the resurrected bodies are us in a radically extended way. Like a plant that grows out of a dead seed, they rise from us but they are new creations, they are new life. In 1:12 Corinthians, for example, the sense of what Paul means by a resurrected body is clearly corporate, “For just as the body is one and has many members, and all the members of the body, though many, are one body, so it is with Christ.” This may strike a mystical chord but it is also suggests a way to think about the end of human life on the planet, and that the work we do will act on the future of the planet. It also counters Agamben’s claim about the messianic as inoperativity, Paul’s ‘new creature’ becomes one that stimulates action. What comes after us will live with our choices. As Paul and Heidegger suggest, this is a claim about orientation to the future and a call to a politics in which we act with an eye for the distant future, of new living beings. Instead of falling into despair at our disappearance Paul suggests that we act as if our political action may not be for us.