Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Epistemological Compatibility of Critical Approaches and Statistical Modelling

Fri, October 1, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Critical IR has been ambivalent about the usefulness of quantitative methods for generating critical knowledge. While some, especially US-based critical scholars have embraced quantitative methods as a necessary toolkit for validation of critical insights, others have they have been doubtful about their appropriateness for critical research. Recently, there seems to be a renewed push for a methodological synthesis of quantitative methods and critical research (Barkin and Sjoberg, 2017) on the grounds of their epistemological neutrality and thus inherent compatibility with any research approach. In this paper, I argue that quantitative methods, particularly statistical modelling, are in fact not epistemologically neutral but, instead, are firmly embedded in neopositivist assumptions about what phenomena, conceptualisation and relationships can be included and hence what knowledge claims can be generated through their use. I argue that the epistemological assumptions of most critical approaches give rise to concepts and relations in substantive theory that often cannot be meaningfully translated into a statistical model which necessarily requires neopositivist forms of knowledge (in terms of both concept operationalisation and the model itself). This results in a logical inconsistency of the research design – the inadequate alignment between theory and model leads to a considerably diminished ability of the methods to validate hypotheses and, similarly, the interpretation of the results vis-à-vis the theory becomes problematic since the results speak to concepts and relations that do not exist in the theory. I demonstrate my argument on the existing research on gender and IR to show that the compatibility of critical feminist conceptualisations of gender with statistical methods is very limited and thus the epistemic usefulness of these methods for critical study of gender rather minimal.

Author