Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Building Roots: Electoral Systems, Intra-party Democracy and Social Linkages

Sat, October 2, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

This paper explores the connection between electoral systems and intra-party democracy (IPD) as key institutional determinants for party-society linkages from cross-party and cross-national perspectives. A considerable body of electoral systems' literature emphasizes that candidate-centered electoral systems – which encourages candidates to cultivate personal instead of party reputations – promote intraparty competition and unrooted party organizations (Carey and Shugart, 1995; Colomer, 2011). Nonetheless, there is little comparative empirical analysis of how party organizations have strategically responded (or adapted) to electoral rules changes toward institutional personalization (Renwick and Pilet, 2016; Cross, Katz and Pruysers, 2019). In fact, most of these analyses have an omitted variable bias by excluding the party level dimensions (Hopkin, 2009). Our paper addresses two questions: 1) Do the candidate-centered electoral systems impact the development of party-society linkages? 2) If the electoral system has any impact, does it occur directly or mediated by the intra-party democracy levels? We expect that candidate-centered electoral systems are negatively associated with the development of strong party ties with society (DV: specific social group support and presence of affiliate organizations), but only in party organizations with high inclusiveness levels in the intra-party decision-making process (IV: candidate selection, internal party cohesion, and presence of local party office) – high IPD levels (Poguntke et al., 2016; Cross and Katz, 2013). When the decision-making process concentrates power in a few's hands, party elites can solve the coordination problems and mitigate personalization consequences. We rely on the two most extensive and updated cross-national datasets to date on party organizations and elections, both based on expert evaluations: V-Party Dataset (Lührmann et al., 2020) and V-Dem Dataset (Coppedge et al., 2020). Following the tradition of the 'most different' approach in a comparative analysis of party organizations (Janda, 1980), we employ a database with 654 parties in 40 countries (with more than 10 million inhabitants) covering third-wave democracies, post-communist countries, and advanced democracies in the Americas (Latin and North America) and Europe (Western and Eastern Europe), between 1988 and 2018. All parties included won at least 5% of votes in one national legislative election. We opted not to add authoritarian regimes (Freedom House, 2020). To test the hypothesis, we built two time series models with fixed effects, establishing multiple country-level heterogeneity controls. The very preliminary conclusions suggest that the organizational dimensions may assume a more central role in the debate both as an explanatory variable per se or associated with the electoral systems, capable of influencing political outcomes (party-society linkages).

Authors