Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Traditional approaches to political leadership tend to focus on the knowledge and skills that individual persons need to achieve their goals in elective or appointed positions of authority atop organizational hierarchies. Against that, I contrast a feminist pragmatist approach drawn from the writings and leadership practices of Jane Addams, Nobel Peace Prize laureate, co-founder of Chicago’s Hull House settlement, and leader in the women’s international peace movement. Addams focuses on how activists at the forefront of publics—understood as pluralist communities formed by a perceived need to respond to a common issue or problem (Addams 1902, Dewey 1927) —facilitate achievement of goals shared with others. I show how Addams contributes to an understanding of political leadership, especially democratic leadership of pluralist publics that include the poor and marginalized.
In both traditional and pragmatist approaches to political leadership, the epistemology of leaders is key. Yet, traditional approaches have not closely examined the epistemic process through which leaders learn what they need to know. Certainly traditional approaches consider what kinds of experiences are useful, or what habits of mind or collaborative skills should be cultivated. However, they tend to gloss over the developmental, epistemic process through which leaders acquire and exercise the requisite knowledge and skills. What exactly do political leaders learn? How? From whom or from what experiences? Through what epistemic process do they translate the knowledge they acquire into action that achieves common goals?
Contemporary feminist epistemology provides insights into these questions of leadership epistemology—concepts such as situational knowledge, relational knowledge, and standpoint theory, all of which point to the relational and collective context through which leaders acquire and exercise knowledge. I suggest that sympathetic knowledge, a collective and relational form of knowledge described by Jane Addams (Hamington 2018; Addams 1902, 1912), captures these insights in contexts that are directly related to democratic political leadership (Hamington 2018, Addams 1902, 1912). Addams advises settlement house residents on development epistemic process that offers sympathetic knowledge: To be helpful to the neighborhood, they must first empty themselves “of all conceit of opinion and all self-assertion, and [be] ready to arouse and interpret the public opinion of their neighborhood. They must be content to live quietly side by side with their neighbors, until they grow into a sense of relationship and mutual interests” (Addams, 1902).
To understand better the contribution that Addams makes to epistemology of democratic political leaders, I compare her notion of sympathetic knowledge with another concept often used by leadership scholars—Aristotelian prudence, often translated as practical wisdom or judgment (Steinberger 2014; Foley 2013; Keohane 2012; Moskop 2011, 1996; Beiner 1983). Prudence is the virtue that Aristotle attributes to individual political leaders who can achieve good for humans, such as the Athenian general and statesman Pericles. Beyond its use by leadership scholars, prudence is helpful to my project because feminist scholars have pointed out similarities between Aristotelian prudence and feminist relational and contextual concerns (Eubanks 2012; Freeland 1998). The idea is that leadership approaches that focus on prudence as a virtue of individual leaders are conceptually open to collective and relational epistemology of sympathetic knowledge, whether or not proponents of these approaches recognize that. Ultimately, the comparison between prudence and sympathetic knowledge shows how Addams’s approach to leadership through sympathetic knowledge carries a developmental epistemic process that serves democratic political leadership. Conversely, to the extent that traditional leadership approaches focus narrowly on the knowledge of individual agents, apart from the relational, collective contexts that shape leaders’ knowledge and possibilities for exercising that knowledge, such approaches overlook an epistemic process that can serve democratic leadership.