Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Delayed Justice: The Effects of Land Restitution in South Africa

Sat, October 2, 1:30 to 2:00pm PDT (1:30 to 2:00pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

While programs of restorative justice aim to compensate a specific group of people for past injustices through generous benefits, they also can create high, legalistic barriers for any person who claims compensation. In this paper, I ask what effects such onerous claims processes have on their participants. Do citizens who undergo a formal claims process become more politically active or do they change their attitudes around restorative justice? To answer these questions, I compare Black South Africans who experienced land dispossession and made a formal land restitution claim to those who did not make a claim despite having experienced land dispossession. Using survey data from 2004 on land reform attitudes in South Africa, I find that while land claimants are more likely to undertake land-based protests than those who did not enter into the process, they also hold marginally less progressive views on which groups should be included in their generous land restitution programs. I argue that this stems from their experience in a slow, onerous and demanding legal battle to claim compensation. Formal beneficiaries must undertake activism to push their claim through, but they may also become distrustful of delayed state benefits or protective of their own hard-fought status. I triangulate my analysis with evidence from qualitative interview that details the difficulties encountered by Black South Africans in the land restitution process. Ultimately, I conclude that while restorative justice mobilizes claimants in that they pursue their claim, an onerous claims process may actually politically demobilize the very people it hopes to assist.

Author