Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Engendering Democratic Passions: Reform in Spinoza’s "Political Treatise"

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

Spinozism is now synonymous with a metaphysical system, but regarding political matters, Baruch Spinoza insisted political practitioners wrote more effectively than philosophers. The non-ideal political theory in his Political Treatise (1677) turns towards practical institutional reforms as bulwarks against popular feelings of resentment, so they are timely to revisit in the contemporary U.S. political climate. Spinoza offers practical constitutional proposals that increase opportunities for democratic office holding and for market access.

Recent Spinoza scholarship argues his practical political theory stands free of his ideal theory (e.g., Steinberg 2018) and represents a conservative turn after he witnesses mob violence in The Hague (e.g., James 2018). I argue, however, that Spinoza envisions a gradual and self-supporting program of democratic reform to realign the passions characteristic of different non-democratic regimes. Spinoza grounds the validity of his political science in his contemplation of human affects as non-moral natural phenomena, as if the passions were temperatures or storms (TP 1.5). His practical institutional proposals shape the affects in ways that ought to be self-supporting, according to the moral psychology in Parts III and IV of the Ethics.

In the Ethics, Spinoza regards envy as the primary obstacle to cooperation and democracy. Based on his own marrano experience in the seventeenth-century Netherlands, Spinoza is aware of the ways commercial republics create opportunities for empowerment, and is simultaneously concerned with nativist envy of successful immigrants. I argue that the institutional reforms of the Political Treatise, which regulate elections, terms of office-holding, lending, and land ownership, are designed to avoid problems of envy that arise in different ways in monarchy and aristocracy. Institutions that shape desire for money and democratic offices encourage cooperation, whereas desires for land and titles created the conditions for zero-sum competition. Therefore, Spinoza never abandons his commitments to democracy or to his philosophy. The Political Treatise envisions practical ways to gradually turn non-democratic regimes into commercial republics, consistent with the moral psychology we find in the Ethics.

Author