Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Dual Accounts of Tyranny in Plato’s Republic

Thu, September 30, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

Understanding tyranny is essential to political life. Yet, recent attempts to analyze the phenomenon have overlooked the importance of understanding the tyrant as an individual—they neglect to study the psychology of tyranny. The political science of the ancients, on the other hand, makes the soul of the tyrant the core of its treatment of tyranny. Tyranny is bad for the ruler as well as the ruled. However, one of the most famous ancient treatments of tyranny, the Republic, presents two differing pictures of tyranny that differ in their character. In Book Eight, Plato provides a very sober picture of the tyrant as one who emerges from the democratic leader of the people through a series of ever escalating bloodthirsty actions. The tyrant in Book Eight is an ambitious and competent political actor, one who is able to use the passions of the city for his own advantage. However in Book Nine, the tyrant’s character drastically changes. Gone is the impressive figure from Book Eight and in his place we find an eros addict who is a slave to his own desires. It is difficult to imagine how this could be the same man described in Book Eight. Thus, one of the challenges presented by the Republic is to understand the connection between these two differing accounts of tyranny. Ultimately, it seems that while Book Eight describes the tyrant as he exists in political reality, the tyrant is used by Plato in Book Nine to show the choiceworthiness of the philosophic life.

Author