Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

A Confucian Version of Nationalism from Family to the World

Sat, October 2, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Abstract

With a comparative approach, in this paper I am going to introduce a Chinese theory of nationalism, which is very different from ideas in the liberal tradition. This theory originated from Confucian classics such as Analects and Mencius and was developed by a thinker named Liang Qichao in the early 1990s. It not only represents the Confucian ideal of the nation which was the root of ancient China as an empire, but also shows an open attitude towards diverse culture and could contribute to the contemporary discussion of nationalism and globalization.
In recent years, globalization is encountering a crisis, as more and more right-wing populists refer to nationalism to claim against immigration and regional integration. Scholars like David Miller and Bernard Yack defend nationalism from the liberal tradition, but it is still generally accredited that nationalism as a political ideology is firmly against globalization and may result in national conflicts. Theories of nationalism in non-Western tradition do not get enough attention because the distinction between Western and Eastern nationalism emphasized by scholars like Hans Kohn, John Plamenatz and Anthony Smith usually regards Eastern nationalism as mostly ethnic, oppressive and exclusive. However, such misunderstanding should be revised, as it focuses merely on some modern practices of nationalism in the Eastern world but seldom studies the non-Western understandings of the nation in theory carefully.
Unlike the Western theory of nationalism based on self-identity and the sense of national community, for Confucianism, family rather than the individual is the basic unit of society, which means that every individual’s self-identity could not be understood without referring to the family relationship. That is to say, an individual as a member of the nation is not defined by features like ethnicity or race, but by how he or she corresponds with the virtues to live in the family. Family also influences the sense of national community at the same time because Confucianism regards the national state and even the whole world as a family in a broader scope. With the blurred boundary between the national state and the world, people’s attitudes towards so-called foreigners from different nations become friendly. As a result, although Confucian nationalism is neither civic nor democratic, it would also be wrong to call it ethnic, hostile or exclusive. Considering the structure from family to the world in Confucian thought, as well as the role of virtues such as benevolence (Ren) and reciprocity (Shu), Confucian nationalism is mostly inclusive and defensive. It seeks for a better world with tight connections as well as friendly relationships among different nations. Therefore, this non-Western theory of nationalism challenges our general impression of the relationship between nationalism and globalization, and should be explored carefully.
My paper will start with a brief criticism of the misleading distinction between Western and Eastern nationalism, which leads to the necessity of comparative studies. Then the main body will be the introduction to the ancient Chinese theory of nationalism and Liang Qichao’s development in the modern world. After the detailed explanation, I would like to reveal how Confucianism could provide new inspirations to the current discussion of nationalism and globalization.

Author