Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
There is plenty of scholarship criticizing various aspects of Marx’s (and Engels’) oeuvres from different perspectives and even from a range of different disciplines (economics, philosophy, sociology, political science, history, etc.), and there is even serious consideration of countering popular tropes about (i.e., against) Marxism (e.g., Fromm 1961; Eagleton 2018; and Katch 2015; 2017). However, contrary to the manner in which these popular tropes are analyzed, critiqued, and responded to in this recent literature, this paper will show, albeit speculatively, how many of the most common slogans, assumptions, and outright lies (or hypocrisies and double-standards) levied against socialism (Marxism, communism, etc.) are, or could reasonably interpreted to be, reflective of two distinct but related problems that are not simply ideological distortions of Marxian thought but actually integral to this socialist tradition.
First, most popular opposition to Marxism centers on different interpretations, whether intentionally or not, of the Marxian axiom, “from each according to their ability, to each according to their need.” This central organizing principle of Marx’s vision for a postcapitalist world isn’t exactly specific on a lot of issues that this slogan implicates. For example, the quote doesn’t clearly account for questions, such as: how is society (or who within society is) to determine what constitutes a need, how will people’s abilities be measured or evaluated, what kind of governance or accountability system will be in place to adjudicate disagreements and/or violations of whatever is agreed to or decided, and what will be the political processes for ensuring democratic social control over the determinations made.
The second problem is that people who are psycho-socially conditioned by capitalism reasonably don’t take well to considering how they would fit into an entirely different social order, even if they despise the status quo or many aspects of it. People tend to evaluate political ideologies based on their values and what they consider to be the kind of society they would want to live in, within the confines of what they imagine to be practically possible. This is a problem because, as Mark Fisher (2009) and Erich Fromm (1955) in different ways suggested, capitalism forms, reforms, alters, distorts, and otherwise shapes and limits its systemic inhabitants’ sense of what is realistic, possible, and/or desirable. Thus, the second problem, more simply put, is that people within capitalist society genuinely find many proposed facets of a socialist future uncomfortable, foreign, and undesirable (or at least how these proposals are being imagined). There are of course plenty of bad faith uses of anti-socialist rhetoric, and it is fair to say this is most of what we see predominate in party politics, in the traditional media, and on social media and the wider internet. However, this likely fact doesn’t eliminate the parallel reality that there are indeed real concerns among people about what socialists are actually desirous of; that is, this paper takes seriously the possibility that people are actually concerned about the actual goals of socialism. Perhaps most crucially, it will be argued that these well-intentioned (or un-intentioned) anxieties are structural-ideological dimensions of the capitalist system itself.
These two problems are problems for Marxism on its own terms, but they are far from insurmountable. Because at the same time they are problems to the achievement of a democratic, egalitarian postcapitalism, they also capture the dialectical contradictions-- with their variably positive and negative potentials-- of the Marxist critique of capitalism and the principles that form the basis of Marx’s desired future alternative to capitalism.