Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Responding especially to the sense of environmental crisis, the last few years have seen a rise in the use of the words planet and planetary in in cultural and political discourse. This “planetary turn” is reflected in some of Political Theory’s cognate disciplines, with planetary perspectives now on offer in sociology, literary studies, and International Relations. In this paper, I examine the rise of what I call “planet-talk” in Political Theory, bringing clarity to the various evocations of the planet which have so far been only loosely theorized.
My research finds that planet-talk is not new, and dates back to before the rise of environmental consciousness of recent decades. The central claim of the paper is that running through political theory there is what I call a subterranean fear of planetary thought. I distinguish the term planet from other words that describe the human habitat such as world, earth, and globe. I show that in some important twentieth century political thinkers, planet specifically denotes a world stripped of meaning and purpose, the home of humanity reduced to a mere astronomical object. I draw on scholarship in cultural and visual studies to depict the de-centering and dis-enchantment caused by astronomical developments, space exploration, and the first photographs of the Earth.
Within Political Theory, the reception of these ideas and images was one of fear and anxiety that tapped into wider worries about modernity and alienation. Here I focus on a synoptic overview of thinkers who I read as evincing a “fear of the planet”, ranging from Martin Heidegger and Hannah Arendt in the phenomenological tradition, to thinkers like Carl Schmitt. Politically, this anxiety was expressed in the form of worries about the unification of humanity, the erosion of borders and boundaries, and the dangers of a world government.
My paper shows that these political concerns were linked to a worry about the epistemic vision which made the astronomical view of the planet possible. Our sense of our habitat as a home, as the ground for meaning, was seen as threatened by the scientific, astronomical, view of the Earth as a mere planet, as Martin Heidegger put it, a “mass of matter deposited somewhere”. What made viewing the Earth as a mere planet possible was the scientific view of humanity and our role in the cosmos, that is, alienation from the senses, from common sense, and from the world around us in its concrete immediacy. This, in turn, meant that to see our habitat as a planet was to see and experience ourselves as certain kinds of beings, both too animal and too machine-like.
I conclude with the suggestion that if Political Theory is to undergo a planetary turn, it must reckon with this tradition of fear of a “blank” planet. To begin such a reckoning, I contrast the above fear of the planet with ideas from Black Political Thought and Afro-futurism, focusing on Leopold Senghor. I find a curious relationship between the fear of a blank planet, a view of our habitat as a planet in a non-anthropocentric universe devoid of inherent meaning, and the fear of a Black planet, of a world where national and racial boundaries have been exploded.