Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
In our paper, we contribute to the advancement of formalized multimethod research and develop Bayesian nested analysis (BNA). BNA differs in four ways from the original, frequentist version of nested analysis (FNA) that so far has been at the center of empirical and methods-oriented work.
First, Bayesian nested analysis with at least one quantitative and qualitative stage allows researchers to formally use the knowledge gained with one method to inform the implementation of the other method in the next stage. We explain in detail how empirical researchers can use a Bayesian framework to introduce prior knowledge at the three interfaces of qualitative and quantitative methods in nested analysis. The forward-movement of knowledge from one stage of the analysis to the next is generic to nested analysis as a sequential mixed-methods design and can only be properly formalized in a Bayesian framework.
Second, for deriving cues from the regression results for process tracing, the estimates must be
informative about the probability that an effect is present, the size of the effect and its direction. We demonstrate that the frequentist interpretation of regression estimates does not meet this requirement and introduces a fundamental incoherence in nested analysis. We further show that the Bayesian interpretation of regression estimates allows one to seamlessly integrate process tracing in the quantitative analysis.
Third, BNA allows empirical researchers to operate within a coherent Bayesian framework and to
integrate Bayesian regression analysis with Bayesian process tracing in the second stage.
We present a fully developed framework for Bayesian nested analysis that follows the original template of frequentist nested analysis. The BNA framework is illustrated step by step with a reanalysis of a leading empirical example from colonialism research and Monte Carlo simulations.