Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Rating Like a State: China’s Social Credit System

Sat, October 2, 12:00 to 1:30pm PDT (12:00 to 1:30pm PDT), TBA

Abstract

How does the Chinese state construct “good” and “bad” citizenship? Our research addresses the puzzle by examining top-down state constructions of citizenship via the Social Credit System (SCS). Specifically, we analyze all 66 national-level policy documents demarcating trustworthy and untrustworthy behavior by citizens, as laid out by the central state. Combining this with 135 media articles reporting on specific cases of citizenship behavior and a case study of a local state’s implementation of SCS, we find three distinct features of citizenship construction via the Social Credit system. First, a “good” citizen is one who engages in state-supported civic participation
either online or offline, rather than a disengaged citizen. In contrast, a “bad” citizen is one who
violates rules and laws and/or participates in contentious political participation. Hence, a bad
citizen is not simply demarcated via political behaviors. Second, the Social Credit system also
constructs collective citizenship, thus going beyond rating individual behavior. To this end, the
system demarcates “good” and “bad” social organizations in an effort to cultivate a state-led civil society. Third, local states interpret and develop their own rating and implementation criteria to discipline “bad” local citizens who engage in undesirable political participation. Altogether, this
study reveals how the Chinese state goes about “seeing like a state” (Scott 1990) via top-down
social engineering of its population.

Authors