Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Democratic Deliberation and Gene Editing

Wed, September 29, 1:30 to 5:30pm PDT (1:30 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: In-Person Short Course Half Day

Session Description

Commitments to collective problem solving in the U.S. are eroding. In pluralistic societies, it is important for the different ethnic groups and social classes to recognize and value that they share a common purpose or they will devolve into self-interested tribes jockeying for power. In this short course, we will explore the potential for collective problem solving about the use of gene editing technologies to modify populations of wild organisms, such as mosquitoes, which might be done by creating and releasing large numbers of modified individuals or by means of gene drives that force a modification from a few individuals through a population.
Gene editing proposals have significant potential benefits, risks, and uncertainties, both for human welfare and for aspects of the shared environment that are valued in themselves. Given the values at stake, commentators have argued that the proposals require public engagement and that such engagement should be deliberative. There is a consensus that usual governance processes alone will not address key concerns about genetically modified organisms adequately. In the course, we will review the literature on democratic deliberation and reflect on whether appropriately structured deliberations can achieve this goal.
While the calls for public deliberation are ubiquitous, there has been less discussion about how such deliberations should be conducted. In this course, we will discuss how to structure deliberations. In particular, we will discuss debates about how to represent the public. Some scholars argue that it is crucial to include a statistically representative sample of the population in public deliberations because doing so is more likely to generate findings that will be accepted by policy makers. Other scholars argue that it is crucial to over-sample groups that have been historically under-represented. For example, Native Americans, may have different values about the human relationship with nature that should be included in these deliberations. We will explore the implications of these competing perspectives.

Sub Unit

Chair

Presenter