Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Homelands and Territorial Conflict

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Author meet critics

Session Description

This author meets critics roundtable brings together leading experts on territorial conflict for a discussion of Nadav Shelef’s book, Homelands: Shifting Borders and Territorial Disputes (Cornell University Press, 2020).

Few things are as instinctively durable as a nation’s desire for its homeland. The Jewish pining for the land of Israel, the Palestinian struggle for the same territory, the Hungarian dream of the pre-Trianon borders, and the Serbian drive to regain Greater Serbia are all piercing reminders of the persistence of lost homeland territory in the national imagination - and of the conflict that often follows. Our instincts, however, are only partially right. Such poignant cases notwithstanding, there are many, often unnoticed, instances of once voluble claims to lost homeland territory melting away. Indian nationalists no longer claim Lahore as part of “Mother India.” Germans rarely seek the return of the German homeland east of the Oder and Neisse Rivers. Even Italian nationalism, whose aspirations for its terra irredenta (unredeemed land) along the Adriatic coast gave us the term “irredentism,” no longer widely includes Istria or Dalmatia within the geographical scope of the Italian homeland.

Shelef’s book shows how such transformations in the area included in the homeland come about and explores their consequences for international conflict. The book makes three fundamental arguments. First, we should take seriously the psychological and emotional value of homelands to nationalists. Losing homeland territory structures both domestic politics and international conflict in ways that losing other kinds of territory does not. Second, the value of homelands notwithstanding, homelands should be treated as a variable whose value varies over time rather than as a static indicator. Doing so allows us to move beyond debates about the role of perceived indivisibility in territorial conflict to an explicit investigation of the mechanisms that drive changes in the definition of the homeland’s scope and the conditions that make such change more likely. Finally, drawing inspiration from evolutionary processes, the book argues that homelands can change because they are often characterized by domestic variation about what constitutes the homeland and why certain parcels are part of it, the differential success of political movements promoting alternative variants, and, in the right institutional context, time for the positive political returns to this success to enable variants associated with political success to spread more widely in a society (even if they are not the reason for the success, per se). Both the case studies and the cross-national analysis that follow show how this process, one rooted in the consequences of domestic political contestation, explains when and how lost parts of the homeland come to be excluded from definitions of the homeland’s extent.

Shelef’s book bridges the persistent gap between constructivist theories of nationalism and quantitative empirical analyses of international conflict by developing systematic, comparable, data about the homeland status of lost territory that are both consistent with constructivist understandings of homelands and can be used in systematic positivist quantitative analysis.

This author meets critics panel brings together leading experts on conflict and adjacent fields from a variety of methodological perspectives for a critical discussion of the implications of integrating homelands as a dynamic variable into scholarship on international conflict in ways that continue to transcend the conventional divisions in the study of territorial conflict.

Sub Unit

Chair

Presenters