Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

State Capacity in Historical Perspectives: China and Beyond

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel

Session Description

What are the determinants of the rise and decline of state capacity overtime and across societies? These questions have generated renewed scholarly debates on the origins of state capacity and its role on state-society relations. One strand of recent inquiries revisits states’ political development from a historical perspective, aiming to understand the origins and long-term impacts of state building. Our panel brings together four papers that offer new theoretical arguments and empirical evidence to contribute to this debate. Importantly, these papers explore the fundamental questions and enduring puzzles concerning state building and political development in China and Europe, using formal models and drawing on qualitative and quantitative evidence based on new historical records. One commonality across all papers on the panel is that they propose new logics that extend our understanding of state building and political order beyond earlier scholarship informed by experiences in early modern European states.

The first two papers tackle this question by investigating long-run historical development prior to the 20th century. The first paper by Jia, Roland, and Xie proposes a theoretical framework to understand the relationship between power concentration and political stability. The authors first use historical narratives to present an interesting puzzle that Medieval Europe with stronger rule of law and property rights actually experienced greater numbers of wars than Imperial China did. The authors then develop a formal model to explore the impacts of power sharing structure on political stability in Medieval Europe and Imperial China. Specifically, the authors identify the political–economic tradeoffs behind struggles of power sharing among elites, which lead to different equilibria of political stability.

The second paper by Wang embarks an ambitious endeavor to explain the temporal variation of China’s political development since 200BCE. Wang argues the durability of Chinese imperial rule rests on the degree of state elite’s social embeddedness—political instability emerges when the state elites lose connection with society, thus rendering stronger social forces that could threaten the state’s control of society. Wang offer supporting evidence based on an original dataset on Chinese rulers, taxation, conflicts, and elite networks over a millennium.

The next two papers zoom into the political development in the 20th century in order to shed new light into question of state building and political order in authoritarian regimes. The paper by Lü turns the attention to the early 20th century in China by focusing on the critical juncture of the Sino-Japanese War (1937-1945). Lü argues that the rise of the CCP and the demise of the KMT during the War offers a rare window of opportunity to study the origins of resilience and fragility of authoritarian parties. Specifically, both the KMT and the CCP faced domestic and foreign adversaries while scrambling to extract financial resources to finance the War, and they adopted distinctly different strategies in party building and fiscal extraction. Specifically, the CCP relied on grassroots party organizations while the KMT relied on existing local elites for policy implementation and tax compliance. Using both qualitative and quantitative evidence from a variety of previously underutilized internal party archives in the 1930s and 1940s, Lü shows that fiscal extraction strategies adopted by the CCP and the KMT generated different impacts on fiscal capacity building and mass resistance.

The last paper by Mattingly focuses on the role of military in autocratic regime transitions. Using a formal model, Mattingly illustrates the way through which shifts in civilian elite’s control over the military plays a key role on elite power struggles and the frequency of warfare with foreign countries. Specifically, Mattingly maintains that the competition to the control over military could spark elite purging and foreign conflicts, resulting in political disorders. Using archival evidence, Mattingly provides supporting evidence by analyzing an original dataset of over 150,000 appointments to top posts in the People’s Liberation Army from 1949 to the present.

Sub Unit

Chair

Discussants

Individual Presentations