Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel
What does it mean for the US to have elected its second Catholic president? Joe Biden’s win is historic for many reasons, not least his success in unseating an incumbent president. With Biden’s election, the US has also elected only its second Catholic president. While less flashy than his victory over the polarizing Trump, Biden’s Catholicism offers an important key to why Biden was reelected, and how he will govern. With a Catholic president political scientists will have renewed urgency and opportunities to study questions that have bedeviled them for years. For while the complex dynamics of religion and politics have been studied extensively with respect to the Religious Right in the U.S., far less attention has been paid to religious identity, behavior and practice on the Left. Moreover, a preponderance of scholarship on religion and politics in the US has focused on evangelical Protestantism. But amidst ever-increasing religious pluralism, the US is experiencing a “Catholic moment” in federal governance, with the Catholic Nancy Pelosi as speaker of the House, 30% of the House membership, and six Catholics Supreme Court justices, including Chief Justice Roberts. What does this portend for future Catholic influence in US politics? Biden’s presidency offers a chance to interrogate such questions.
Panelists will question the role of Catholicism in Biden’s campaign and administration; its significance for his governance and policy; and its meaning for his place in US history. The panel will reflect the methodological pluralism of political science, with empirical and qualitative methods; the subfield pluralism of American politics, public policy and political theory; as well as an interdisciplinary pluralism that has always characterized political science, borrowing from history, economics, sociology, and religious studies. The panel also conceptually approaches “religion” pluralistically: in terms of belief, behavior and belonging.
Two panelists break down the election of Biden as a Catholic. Is there a “Catholic vote”, and does it matter in an age of religious pluralism? The question received renewed urgency in 2016, when Catholics broke for the losing candidate but supplied critical support for Trump in swing states. Biden himself responded to that development by vigorously deploying his Catholic identity on the campaign trail. But did it matter? Our first panelist breaks down and offers a tentative response to such questions. Further, how did Biden succeed in becoming only the second Catholic president? How does he navigate the tensions between Catholic religious beliefs and the pragmatic political practices of multicultural, religiously pluralistic state? Our second panelist will consider the hard choices Biden has had to make in facing such questions, with particular reference to his relationship with the Catholic hierarchy.
How will Catholicism influence Biden’s policy? What does it mean for Biden to be a Catholic politician? Two of our panelists focus on such questions. One explores the fundamental “personalism” at work in Catholic political thought and practice, the “radical love of neighbor” that makes Biden’s politics deeply relational. That relationality is quite foreign to the American ethos of rugged individualism, but less so to other traditions in the US today, especially those of recent immigrants. How has such personalism shaped Biden, and how through him will it shape US politics? Another set of questions relates to secularism, an important but complex phenomenon that our fourth panelist takes up through the work of Charles Taylor. How should Biden as a Catholic president approach a society characterized by a diverse array of beliefs? What contribution as a Catholic can Biden make to the political contours of that secularism? This last paper will lay out Taylor’s guidance for Biden on the bounds of the possible, taking refugee policy as a case study.
As Americans begin to make sense of what US politics will look like after the Trump presidency, this panel seeks to underline the significance of religion for the Biden presidency. We have great faith that it offers important vistas for situating Biden within the present moment, and for illuminating possible paths into the future.
The Catholic Vote in 2020: Did Biden's Catholic Identity Matter? - Mark J. Rozell, George Mason University
The Second United States Catholic President - Jo Renee Formicola, Seton Hall University
The Personal is the Political: Biden and Personalism Come to the White House - Christopher M. Duncan, Saint Louis University
Charles Taylor on the Moral Imaginary of the Biden Presidency - William A. McCormick, Saint Louis University