Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Session Submission Type: In-Person Author meet critics
Erica De Bruin, How to Prevent Coups d'Etat: Counterbalancing and Regime Survival (Ithaca: Cornell University Press, 2020)
Kristen Harkness, When Soldiers Rebel: Ethnic Armies and Political Instability in Africa (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2018)
Military intervention in politics remains a threat for rulers around the globe. This roundtable brings together scholars of civil-military relations, regime survival, and dictatorship to discuss two recent books on coup-prevention or “coup-proofing” tactics rulers use to remain in power. Kristen Harkness’s When Soldiers Rebel focuses on efforts to stack the military with allied ethnic or sectarian groups. Drawing on extensive archival research, cross-national data, and four in-depth comparative case studies, the book looks at the relationship between ethnic armies and political instability in post-independence Africa. Harkness argues that the process of creating and dismantling ethnically exclusionary institutions engenders organized and violent political resistance. Focusing on rebellions to protect rather than change the status quo, Harkness sheds light on a mechanism of ethnic violence that helps us understand both the motivations and timing of rebellion, and the rarity of group rebellion in the face of persistent political and economic inequalities along ethnic lines.
While Harkness’s book focuses on ethnic stacking, How to Prevent Coups examines another common coup-proofing tactic: counterbalancing the military with presidential guards, militarized police, and other security forces. Erica De Bruin shows that while counterbalancing can be effective in preventing successful coup attempts, the resentment that it generates within the regular military can provoke new coup attempts. The book draws on an original, cross-national dataset of state security forces and archival evidence on coup attempts in Africa, Latin America, and the Middle East. Understanding the dynamics of counterbalancing, she shows, can help analysts predict when coups will occur, whether they will succeed, and how violent they are likely to be.
Taken together, the books show that how leaders organize and staff their coercive institutions can have a profound effect on the survival of their regimes. In contrast to much previous work, which has credited such strategies with fostering civilian control of the military, both When Soldiers Rebel and How to Prevent Coups emphasize that while there are important steps rulers can take to “coup-proof” their regimes, they are risky to pursue.
The aim of this roundtable is to synthesize insights from both books and draw out the broader strategic logics that underpin rulers’ efforts to remain in power. De Bruin and Harkness will begin the roundtable with a presentation identifying the next logical step in the research agenda put forth in their books. In particular, it will explore the conditions under which rulers choose one coup proofing tactic over others and how the two tactics discussed in their books, ethnic stacking and counterbalancing, may work in tandem with one another. This will be followed by a critical discussion bringing diverse regional (Africa, East Asia, Europe, North America) and substantive (autocratic politics, civil-military relations, and political violence) expertise to bear on the two books and the joint research agenda they have engendered. Panelists include Risa Brooks, Sabine Carey, Sheena Greitens, Phil Roessler, and Theodore McLauchlin.