Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The U.S. Campaign Finance System and Consequences for Representation

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: In-Person Full Paper Panel

Session Description

With the ever-rising costs of electoral campaigns in the United States, money continues to be an important determinant of the emergence and success of political candidates. Moreover, the changing campaign finance landscape--e.g., the rise of small donors and the increasing adoption of online fundraising platforms (e.g., ActBlue and WinRed)--presents new challenges and opportunities for politicians, donors, and interest groups. This panel brings together four papers that highlight a few of the promising directions of research on the effects of the campaign finance system on democratic representation in the United States.

Two of the papers on this panel focus on structural and technological factors that affect the fundraising and electoral success of candidates. Adam Bonica and Jake Grumbach shed light on an important yet under-explored cause of under-representation for people of color in legislatures: the money primary. The racialized system of money in politics in the U.S. presents a disproportionate barrier for prospective candidates of color to enter politics. This is particularly true in the early stages of primary elections, where fundraising success is critical for candidate viability and particularly reliant on elite networks to which minorities have limited access. Bonica and Grumbach construct a data set on congressional candidates' educational and professional backgrounds (including those who filed to run and then drop out before their respective primary elections) and the racial identities and professional backgrounds of campaign donors from 2010 and 2014. Bonica and Grumbach’s analysis of this data set demonstrates how the American campaign finance system is biased against racial minorities, who have been historically excluded from these elite educational and professional networks.

Silvia Kim and Zhao Li examine the implications of WinRed, a digital fundraising platform endorsed by the Republican party, for candidates’ fundraising as well as power dynamics within the GOP. Kim and Li argue that WinRed serves as a public good for the party, since it reduces transaction costs in digital fundraising and creates a centralized data warehouse of contact information and observed conduct of campaign donors. Whether WinRed, like other public goods, suffers from under-provision in the absence of coercion by party leadership (i.e., a suboptimal number of Republican candidates migrate to WinRed) depends on how much individual candidates stand to gain in fundraising by joining the platform. Kim and Li estimate the effects of joining WinRed on Republican candidates’ campaign receipts using an original data set of the timing of candidates’ adoption of WinRed and a difference-in-differences design with various robustness checks. Moreover, Kim and Li explore how WinRed changes the balance of power within the Republican party by analyzing heterogeneity effects across candidates’ legislative, electoral, and demographic characteristics.

The other two papers on this panel explore how campaign donors navigate a changing and increasingly complex political fundraising marketplace. Zachary Albert and Raymond La Raja investigate four structural factors--technological changes, organizational activism, media, and campaign finance laws--that may shape the participation of small donors. Albert and La Raja analyze fundraising platforms (e.g., ActBlue), online campaign solicitation appeals, interviews with fundraisers, and state campaign finance laws. Albert and La Raja discuss whether small donors may ameliorate the distortionary effects of traditional “big money” donors in elections, the incentives that campaigns and political organizations may face in their attempt to court small donors (e.g., appealing to these donors’ consumption values), and implications for descriptive and ideological representation through the campaign finance system.

Last but not least, Zhao Li examines the rise of “scam PACs,” i.e., political action committees (PACs) that raise campaign donations to enrich their creators (such as campaign consultants) instead of advancing the campaigns or causes that they purport to champion. Donors face significant informational barriers to distinguishing scam PACs from bona fide campaigns and political organizations. The proliferation of scam PACs and the lack of regulatory oversight over them not only undermines PACs’ accountability to donors, but also generates a lemons problem in a marketplace for contributions. Li presents a quantitative assessment of scam PACs that have been identified by media and government reports, including these PACs’ distinct expenditure patterns, donor characteristics, treasurer and vendor networks, and communications materials. Building on these descriptive analyses, Li estimates a supervised learning algorithm that systematically identifies scam PACs in U.S. federal elections.

Sub Unit

Cosponsor

Chair

Discussants

Individual Presentations