Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Governance, Law, and Conflict: Legal Pluralism in Post-Conflict Settings

Sat, October 2, 8:00 to 9:30am PDT (8:00 to 9:30am PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: In-Person Full Paper Panel

Session Description

Competing systems of governance during conflict have strong implications for post-conflict peace. This panel investigates varying forms of state and non-state governance and their legal orders that often overlap, interact, and compete in post-conflict settings. It does so from three different starting points: the individual citizen deciding which system to turn to for help with everyday problems; local government officials and development practitioners seeking to evaluate a post-conflict policing program; and finally, an institutional perspective.

Legal plurality is important as incompatibilities between governance systems can lead to conflict recurrence, or conversely, cooperation between state and communal institutions may increase post-conflict security, as the papers by Reyes and Blair et al. included in this panel demonstrate. Reyes examines the effect of incompatible governance systems: an incompatibility that occurs when adversaries have divergent preferences for the legal institutions that serve the fundamental functions of government. Reyes analyzes the relationship between this incompatibility, post-conflict power-sharing institutions, and civil war recurrence with an original, cross-national dataset. Blair et al. investigate whether complementarities between state and communal institutions can be leveraged to improve security and justice, cooperation between state and non-state actors, and reduce citizenry reliance on rebels in Colombia.

Yet, in cases where multiple legal orders are capable of offering citizens solutions, we lack an understanding of when and why citizens turn to different types of legal systems to handle their problems. The existing literature often assumes that an individual considers just one system to be legitimate, when in reality, citizens are likely to select different legal venues for different problems. Employing a survey experiment in post-Islamic State Iraq, Kao and Revkin test the determinants of preferences among alternative justice systems—state, tribal, and Islamic—with important implications for understanding post-conflict governance.

And finally, historical legacies of institutional legal and bureaucratic changes stemming from international aid programs play a critical role in shaping conflict dynamics down the line. Shifting the focus from military aid, which is the predominant starting point in the literature today, Murtazashvilli examines the long-term effects of Soviet “technical” assistance to developing countries that shifted their domestic legal systems and bureaucratic structures. Many of these countries—such as Afghanistan, Somalia, Ethiopia, Yemen, and Mozambique—are embroiled in long-term conflicts today.

The panelists employ a diverse set of methods including survey and field experiments, large-N cross-national statistical analysis, and in-depth case studies. Overall, this proposed panel provides new insights from varied perspectives on legal pluralism, conflict recurrence, and post-conflict state-building and peace.

Sub Unit

Individual Presentations

Chair

Discussant