Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Deliberation and Pluralism

Tue, September 28, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel

Session Description

Our panel explores the norms, methods, and principles that must be followed in order to productively engage across lines of deep disagreement.

Do some forms of moral and political disagreement constitute divisions too deep for successful deliberation to occur? The papers on this panel attempt to answer this question using a plurality of approaches, methods, and case studies.

The paper by Alexandru Marcoci and Alexandra Oprea discusses strategies that may facilitate deliberation across lines of deep disagreement on college campuses, going beyond the usually discussed norms concerning free speech. Simon Niemeyer’s paper goes further to empirically investigate the success of deliberation among citizens expressing seemingly deep disagreements regarding the practice of street begging by internal European migrants. Jeffrey Howard’s paper discusses the normative status of civility norms when one’s political opponents have engaged in egregious forms of injustice. Finally, Diana Popescu’s paper considers the limits of deliberation and recognition in the context of normatively fraught contemporary counter-movements such as “men’s rights” activists and white supremacists.

Overall, the papers consider both the benefits and the limits of democratic deliberation under conditions of both reasonable and unreasonable pluralism.

Sub Unit

Individual Presentations

Chair

Discussants