Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Conflict, Gender and Political Representation

Sun, October 3, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel

Session Description

Recent work on conflict and gender advances a startling finding: conflict and its resolution often precedes women’s political and social empowerment. This panel interrogates this finding’s mechanisms and implications. Combining a range of cases and methods, this panel’s papers investigate how and under what conditions does conflict empower women.

For example, Huber and Brannon explore how women’s participation in conflict impacts their electoral success after conflict. Applying original data on women’s candidacy in local elections with ACLED data from 1962 – 2016 in Uganda, they assess if female candidates are more successful in districts that were exposed to female combatants. They find that female candidates do better in districts where women fought in armed groups, but this success is contingent on the degree of agency that women have in rebel groups, such as voluntary membership, participation in combat roles, and leadership duties.

Bhatia and Monroe’s work in Afghanistan echoes this finding. They use experimental and observational survey data to gauge how insecurity shapes preferences for female political leadership. Their survey experiment primes Afghan respondents with information about the ongoing conflict, followed by a conjoint experiment testing leadership preferences over a range of candidate characteristics, including gender. The insecurity prime dampens support for female political leadership - but only among women. However, the insecurity prime also bolsters women's preferences for male leaders with military experience. Turning to observational data, they demonstrate that Afghan women who report experiencing insecurity are also more supportive of male leadership and the Afghan National Army (AFA) than women who feel secure. Complementing Huber and Brannon’s finding that women’s military participation can boost women’s electoral success in Uganda, Bhatia and Monroe’s research suggests that incorporating women into male-dominated security institutions like the military may help rectify the gender gap in public preferences for leaders in Afghanistan.

Lindsey and Koos study how exposure to conflict-related sexual violence affects social and political participation. Using a list experiment from an original representative survey in eastern Democratic Republic of Congo, Lindsey and Koos find that survivors are remarkably resilient. They are more engaged in their communities even while also being more greatly exposed to stigma. However, the same findings do not hold when using direct measures of conflict-related sexual violence.

Finally, Lake and Berry ask which women benefit from political opportunities after conflict? Employing an extensive comparative analysis of post-conflict gender reform in 10 war-affected contexts across three continents, they find that the implementation of gender egalitarian law and policy often maps onto existing socio-political cleavages. Women affiliated with losing or marginalized identity groups remain sidelined. Reforms heralded as emancipatory and egalitarian in one domain (gender), may reinforce inequalities in another (class, race, region). Post-conflict advancements in women’s political inclusion may be monopolized by women from the winning party.

Together, these papers offer a fresh set of empirical tests and theoretical arguments that nuance our understanding of the relationship between conflict and women’s empowerment. Each paper uses a unique methodological approach, including survey experiments, list experiments, sub-national data, and qualitative data, to trace the complex experiences of women after conflict and the causal mechanisms underlying changes to women’s rights in the wake of political upheaval and violence. The papers highlight the need to challenge assumptions that women’s experiences during and after conflict are a monolith and point to how intersectional and contextual factors, such as class, race, region, exposure to violence, insecurity, and survivor-status, lead to differential outcomes for women after conflict.

Sub Unit

Individual Presentations

Chair

Discussant