Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Dynamics of Rebel Consolidation in Fragmented Civil Conflicts

Sat, October 2, 4:00 to 5:30pm PDT (4:00 to 5:30pm PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: In-Person Full Paper Panel

Session Description

Civil wars and insurgencies can generate hundreds of armed non-state actors with diverse political preferences, ideological worldviews, and state sponsors. This fragmentation invariably produces intense competition and infighting among rivals over territory, resources, and recruits. Crucially, however, fragmentation can give way to political and military consolidation behind one or a few powerful armed organizations. Some groups rise to the top and become hegemonic factions in their militant movements, while others willingly coalesce into grand coalitions with joint political leadership and command structures. Yet, little is known about the processes by which armed non-state actors consolidate power, the conditions conducive to militant consolidation, and the outcomes of these consolidation processes.

In this panel, we are introducing a new research program around the puzzle of militant consolidation in fragmented conflicts. Four sets of authors will explore three mechanisms of consolidation that militant organizations deploy to concentrate greater political and military power in their hands. (1) Cooperative consolidation occurs when a faction grows consensually through alliance formation, mergers, and political coalitions. (2) Competitive consolidation is the process by which a group gains power or influence by outcompeting other factions for fighters, popular support, and external sponsors. (3) Coercive consolidation occurs when one group violently eliminates rivals or compels them to submit to its authority.

Using case studies from Afghanistan, Iraq, and Ukraine, the presenters will explore these modes of militant consolidation, theorize the organizational attributes and conflict conditions that produce different strategies of militant consolidation, and specify the causal mechanisms that contributed to successful or stalled consolidation efforts. These case studies reveal a number of general and contextual causal mechanisms, but three will emerge as salient. The first pertains to ethnic and religious permeability, which can lower barriers to cooperation between co-ethnic and co-religious armed factions. The second revolves around the importance of territorial control on conflictual patterns of consolidation. The third looks at the role of state sponsors and their motivation to see rebels succeed, which can bode well for cooperative strategies of consolidation.

Sub Unit

Individual Presentations

Chair

Discussant