Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Author Meets Critics: On Camila Vergara’s “Systemic Corruption"

Sat, October 2, 6:00 to 7:30am PDT (6:00 to 7:30am PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Author meet critics

Session Description

The economic crises triggered by the 2009 economic crash, a twentieth-first century depression, have once again laid bare the staggering inequalities in both North-Atlantic liberal-democratic orders and at a planetary scale. Equally staggering is the reality of corruption, which is confirmed by almost weekly reports of instances of corruption by elites safely ensconced in positions of power. Yet, in the second decade of the century, these oligarchic orders have been increasingly challenged from below by forms of partisanship that crisscross the traditional political spectrum. Measured against this background, Camila Vergara’s Systemic Corruption: Constitutional Ideas for an Anti-Oligarchic Republic (Princeton University Press, 2020), constitutes a timely and highly original contribution to political theory that is of interest to scholars beyond that subfield. It formulates a conceptual, political and institutional discourse that enables egalitarian political responses to the challenges faced by republican polities beset by the inequalities intrinsic to oligarchic forms of power and the insurrections these foster.

Systemic Corruption provides a compelling and original genealogy of political corruption from ancient to modern thought and shows how representative democracy was designed to protect the interests of the already rich and powerful to the detriment of the majority. Unable to contain the unrelenting forces of oligarchy, especially after the consolidation of neoliberal policies, most liberal democracies have become deeply corrupted oligarchic political orders. By building upon the anti-oligarchic institutional innovations proposed by plebeian political thinkers, Vergara rethinks republican political forms as a mixed order in which popular power is institutionalized to check the power of oligarchy. Drawing on neglected insights from Niccolò Machiavelli, Nicolas de Condorcet, Rosa Luxemburg, and Hannah Arendt, the book proposes to reverse the decay of democracy with the establishment of anti-oligarchic institutions through which common people can collectively resist the domination of the few. Systemic Corruption thus restores and recasts plebeian politics and in one stroke forcefully restores the centrality of plebeian power into theorizations of republicanism and enables the possibility of thinking about plebeian politics as a worthy concern for political theorists.

In this roundtable speakers will be asked to concentrate in different sections of the book. The first section, dedicated to oligarchy, systemic corruption and “materialist constitutionalism,” will be analyzed by critical theorist Onur Ulas Ince and the comparativist Maxwell A. Cameron. The middle section, dedicated to constitutional theory in radical republican thought, will be discussed by republican theorists John P. McCormick and Sonali Chakravarti. The analysis of the final section, which proposes constitutional solutions to the problem of systemic corruption, will be led by the democratic theorist Hélène Landemore.

Sub Unit

Chair

Presenters