Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel
Following the spread of populist politics around the globe, the field of populism research has seen rapid growth over the last decade. Conceptual and methodological diversification yielded a rich understanding of populism in theory and practice. However, scholarship progressed so fast that the field is now on the verge of disintegration before it had time to mature. The panel seeks to integrate the various strands of populism research by building explicit bridges between conceptual development and methodological design. We propose a multidimensional approach to populism, which allows to conceptualize the phenomenon in its entirety, yet without losing analytical clarity. This perspective takes into consideration that populism does not necessarily manifest itself coherently in different dimensions (e.g., communication style, ideology, political organization). Many of the disagreements among scholars in the field may thus be overcome by introducing an integrative concept of populism, together with new frameworks capable of (a) analyzing the phenomenon accordingly to its different manifestations, and (b) developing transversal perspectives by maintaining the developed epistemology. In this spirit, the panel demonstrates how various methodological perspectives may transform conceptual complexity into meaningful theoretical and empirical approach(es), and how such applications “close the loop” by refining our conceptual understanding of populism. In so doing, the panel interlinks theoretical, qualitative, and quantitative research on populism and presents central results of the exchanges between these three approaches.
The new perspective of the proposed panel stresses that populism permeates politics in different levels. One of the novelties of this approach is that populism does not necessarily manifest itself as a coherent phenomenon. As the case of Silvio Berlusconi shows, an actor considered as very populist in their communication style might not defend popular sovereignty or define the elite as the enemy, as the criteria for populism as ideology require. For decades, Berlusconi has divided scholars on populism. The first paper in the panel by Paula Diehl addresses this question, by distinguishing between different dimensions of politics affected by populism and introducing a possible graduation of the phenomenon. This perspective is refined in the contribution by Till Weber, which shows how Diehl’s theoretical approach to conceptual complexity is reflected in the methodology of quantitative analysis. This close link of political theory and advanced statistics demonstrates that the proposed approach to populism can be readily implemented in empirical work.
The following two contributions discuss how methodological innovations can address the multidimensionality of the phenomenon populism. Giorgia Bulli advocates ethnographic methods in populism research. She demonstrates the potential of participant observation for the investigation of right-wing populism in Germany and Italy by focusing on demand and supply of populist mobilization. The final contribution to the panel by Martin Reisigl outlines a politolinguistic approach. It considers how discourse analysis examines populism as a multi-faceted syndrome and emphasizes the importance of a multidisciplinary perspective on the communicative dimension of populism. This methodological proposition is substantiated by empirical cases.
The panel (if accepted) will be sponsored by the journal Polity, and will be submitted there as a symposium after the conference.
For a Complex Definition of Populism - Paula Diehl, Christian Albrechts University of Kiel
Quantitative Populism: Of Shapes and Shades - Till Weber, Baruch College & The Graduate Center, CUNY
Ethnographic Methods in Populism Research: Towards a Multidimensional Approach - Giorgia Bulli, University of Florence
A Politolinguistic Approach to Populism - Martin Reisigl, University of Vienna