Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Explaining Variations in the Success of Pandemic Responses

Wed, September 29, 10:00 to 11:30am PDT (10:00 to 11:30am PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel

Session Description

Covid-19 has deeply disrupted the social and economic life of political systems around the world. In many democracies it has led to burdensome restrictions on personal movement. These include curfews, bans on meetings among different households, closures of schools and all but essential businesses, and the increasing limitations on domestic and international travel. Such incursions on personal freedom are unprecedented in peace time and indeed the crisis posed by the pandemic has in many respects taken on the features of a war. Other restrictions affecting individual behavior such as the requirement to wear masks or remain socially distant have become politically divisive in some polities. Vaccine uptake appears to be becoming politicized in some areas as well. These various efforts to address the pandemic have met with uneven success both politically and in curbing spread of the virus and its resulting morbidity and mortality.

The four papers in this panel aim to explore complementary political and social factors affecting variations in success in addressing the pandemic. These factors include political leadership, federalism, social capital, and expectations formed by histories of experience with public health crises. Panel participants include expertise in politics in the EU, the UK, Italy, Germany, and Japan; in comparative health policy; and in public health policy and law. Panel chair John Francis is Research Professor of Political Science at the University of Utah, where he specializes in British politics, European comparative politics, and comparative public policy. Discussant Tobias Hofmann is visiting professor at the Freie Universität Berlin, Center for European Integration, where he specializes in comparative assessment of compliance in the EU.

Daniel Aldrich and Yitzhak Henry will discuss the role of social infrastructure factors in normed COVID-19 mortality rates. Aldrich is Professor of Political Science, Public Policy and Urban Affairs and Director of the Security and Resilience Studies Program at Northeastern University. Most recently, he is the author of Black Wave: How Connections and Governance Shaped Recovery from Japan’s 3/11 disasters, University of Chicago Press, 2019. Yitzhak Henry is a Ph.D. candidate in political science at Northeastern, specializing in comparative politics and public policy with particular interests in disaster recovery in Latin America and the Caribbean; his methodological work includes not only traditional political science but also the application of GIS and remote sensing technologies.

Leslie Francis and John Francis (non-presenting) test the hypothesis that how authorities and the population acted in the past to contain health crises such influenza outbreaks influence expectations of the need for action and concomitant success in current pandemic management. Leslie Francis is Distinguished Professor of Law and Philosophy and Director of the Center for Law & Biomedical Science at the University of Utah, where she specializes in health law and policy. John Francis is Research Professor in the Department of Political Science at Utah, specializing in British politics, European comparative politics, and comparative public policy. The Francis’s most recent book is Sustaining Surveillance: the Importance of Information for Public Health (Springer, February 2021).

Gillian Peele’s contribution will address the complex ways in which political leadership functions in handling crises such as the pandemic, with particular attention to the case of the UK. Peele is Emeritus Professor in Politics and Tutorial Fellow, Lady Margaret Hall, University of Oxford, where she specializes in empirical politics and British, American and comparative politics. Her recent books include David Cameron and Conservative Renewal: The Limits of Modernization? (coedited with John Francis, Manchester University Press, 2016) and Doing the Right Thing: Regulating Standards in Public Life (with David Hine, Manchester University Press, 2016).

Finally, Lorenzo Pratici will discuss the role of federalism in the Italian health care system’s response to the pandemic. Pratici is a doctoral candidate in Economics and Management of Innovation and Sustainability at the Department of Economics and Management at the University of Parma, where he is also part of the research group Ri.For.Ma which addresses innovative partnerships in public and private health care management.

Sub Unit

Individual Presentations

Chair

Discussant