Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Author Meets Critics: Katrina Forrester's "In the Shadow of Justice"

Sun, October 3, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Author meet critics

Session Description

Katrina Forrester’s award-winning In the Shadow of Justice is the first book to tell the story of how liberal political philosophy was transformed in the second half of the twentieth century under the influence of John Rawls. 2021 marks fifty years since the publication of Rawls’s A Theory of Justice; Forrester’s book is the first to trace its formation, its afterlives, and the rise and legacy of the philosophical movement it created--liberal egalitarianism. It also poses a major challenge to liberal egalitarianism today, raising urgent and timely questions about its significance and relevance.

This Author-Meets-Critics panel brings together commentators from different subfields of political theory to respond to Forrester’s account of the historical Rawls and the story she tells of the transformation of liberal political philosophy. Melissa Lane (Princeton), Murad Idris (UVA), Jacob Levy (McGill), and David Grewal (UCBerkeley) will act as discussants, Alyssa Battistoni (Barnard) as chair, with a response by Forrester (Harvard).

The aim of the panel is to assemble an ideologically-diverse group of political philosophers, historians of political thought, and normative and critical theorists, to interrogate Forrester’s history and her critique. In the Shadow of Justice explores the ascent of Rawlsianism--from its origins among American antistatists and British egalitarians to its encounters with communitarianism, neoliberalism, and analytical Marxism--as well as the rise and consolidation of theories of global and intergenerational justice, civil disobedience, just war, and population ethics. But it also interrogates the very categories and questions that constitute political philosophy today and asks whether liberal egalitarianism can adequately respond to the political crises of our era. The panelists will respond to these provocations. In so doing, they will also offer assessments of Rawls’s A Theory of Justice and the liberal egalitarian tradition today, consider the new political thought scholarship on the “historical Rawls”, and explore the implications of Forrester’s critique for political theorists working on a range of topics--from egalitarianism, justice theory, pluralism and liberalism, to socialist, decolonial, and anti-racist critiques of the liberal tradition. In the Shadow of Justice provides a fresh perspective on liberalism’s ambitions and limits; this panel promises heated debate on what that perspective entails for political theory today.

Sub Unit

Chair

Presenters