Session Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Civil Society and Local Political Pluralism: Evidence from Colombia

Fri, October 1, 2:00 to 3:30pm PDT (2:00 to 3:30pm PDT), TBA

Session Submission Type: Virtual Full Paper Panel

Session Description

Who has access to political rights at the subnational level? What forces restrict or enable political and social inclusion in local politics, and why do pluralistic politics thrive in some subnational regions but not others? Given that many citizens’ first and primary point of contact with the state is on the local level, these questions are critical for understanding the conditions under which pluralism more broadly takes root or fails to do so. Over the last twenty years, these questions have motivated the development of a rich literature on subnational democracy and subnational authoritarian regimes. Scholars have devoted special attention to understanding the ways in which formal state institutions--such as federalism and political parties—act to limit or facilitate local political pluralism. However, less attention has been paid to the roles organized groups in civil society and informal networks and forces play in facilitating or limiting local political pluralism.

This panel sheds light on these questions by bringing together four papers on Colombia: a country that displays marked subnational variation in political inclusion and exclusion, yet has received considerably less attention from scholars of local politics compared to its regional neighbors Brazil, Argentina, and Mexico. Although the papers address the problem of inclusion and exclusion in distinct subnational institutions in Colombia, all three draw attention to a tension between powerful private associations and inclusionary, pluralistic local politics. Jamie Shenk asks why participatory institutions are more accessible to communities in some Colombian localities than others. Relying on an original dataset of post-conflict consultas populares (local referenda) on extractive natural resource projects, she finds that success in organizing referenda is contingent on the consent of NGOs and private corporations, which act as local gatekeepers. Will Freeman explores a different danger to local political pluralism: subnational state capture by private infrastructure contracting firms. Relying on dozens of interviews from fieldwork in the city of Barranquilla, he traces the informal processes by which private sector firms influence decision-making within local government bureaucracies and monopolize access to rents, allowing them to at once generate high levels of public support through delivering much needed public goods while also limiting transparency and competition. Juan Diego Prieto analyzes the varying role of grassroots networks in shaping the distribution of emergency social assistance in urban neighborhoods during the COVID-19 pandemic, identifying the conditions under which these networks can enhance programmatic distribution of aid to hard-to-reach vulnerable households or serve as a tool for clientelistic practices. Juan Albarracín and Juan Pablo Milanese explain a more violent phenomenon that can depress local pluralism: the murder of social leaders. They identify two distinct causal pathways through which alliances between local elites and non-state armed groups explain increased violence against these leaders in the aftermath of the 2016 Colombian peace accords.

Beyond its substantive focus on local pluralism, this panel also advances pluralism in two other respects: first, it brings together scholars of Colombian politics from Colombian Universities (Universidad de los Andes, Universidad ICESI-Cali) and universities outside Colombia (Princeton University, Oxford University). Second, while all the papers are mixed methods, they range from largely quantitative to purely qualitative studies, which nonetheless shed light on a common set of challenges to local pluralism.

Sub Unit

Individual Presentations

Chair

Discussant