Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Virtual Exhibit Hall
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Session Submission Type: In-Person Full Paper Panel
Sharp disputes between religious sects, political factions, and emerging nation-states were only the most manifest examples of the political upheaval and unrest of the seventeenth century. Weary of religious conflicts, political corruption, and popular resentment, the period witnessed a range of revolutionary proposals for how to think through the origin, maintenance, and restraint of political power. Longstanding deference to ideas drawn from faith and history gave way to a new appetite for rational, scientific, and constitutional solutions. The moment invited radical reappraisals of the avenues that existed for political reform and renewal. Seventeenth-century thinkers asked with a new urgency how a lasting peace could be secured and reached for fresh ideas for practical reform.
This panel explores the plurality of approaches to political reform that were offered by some of the most influential thinkers of the century, including James I, Descartes, Hobbes, and Spinoza. Even those theorists who agreed that broad reforms were possible disagreed about what kind of reforms would secure peace most effectively. James and Hobbes advanced the view that reform ought to be sought from the political sovereign himself; Descartes insisted on sweeping moral renewal; Spinoza offered practical institutional proposals.
Beginning in England, the panel’s first paper compares James I and his opponents, the Jesuits, in their debates around the permissibility of popular resistance as a means of checking excesses of power; the author describes how the Jesuits partially concede to James that the king himself is the site and source of political renewal. By contrast, a second paper takes Descartes’s famous obfuscation of direct political advice to reveal his insight that the individual is the appropriate locus for political reform. A further paper highlights Leviathan’s characterization of political unrest as arising from Hobbes’s experience of the French context in which he wrote. The vivid image of competing juridical authorities arguably leads to a new emphasis on total unification of spiritual and temporal realms as the key to ensuring peace. The final paper highlights the way in which Spinoza’s understanding of human passion shapes his practical reform programs, many of which are designed to circumvent the worst of these, envy, by institutional design.
The panel showcases the multiplicity of approaches, and their varied achievements, in order to invite reflection upon the enduring relevance of such approaches, and the potential insights for political reform today.
Obedience, Resistance, and Popular Reform in the Oath of Allegiance Debates - Evelyn Boyden, Harvard University
The Role of Reform in Descartes’s Discourse on Method - Tyler Thomas, University of Notre Dame
Reform as Unification: Hobbes in France & the Uses of Gallican History - Amy Chandran, Harvard University
Engendering Democratic Passions: Reform in Spinoza’s "Political Treatise" - Robert Wyllie, Ashland University