Search
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Mini-Conference
Browse By Division
Browse By Session or Event Type
Browse Sessions by Fields of Interest
Browse Papers by Fields of Interest
Search Tips
Conference
Location
About APSA
Personal Schedule
Change Preferences / Time Zone
Sign In
X (Twitter)
Political scientists have long viewed values as a source of structure and constraint in political belief systems (e.g., Feldman 1988), and more recently as a potential contributor to affective polarization (Enders and Lupton 2021; Lupton, Smallpage, and Enders 2020). Some scholars have argued that differences in moral values, in particular, have contributed to disagreement and hostility between partisan groups (e.g., Clifford 2014; Clifford and Jerit 2013; Haidt 2013). Yet, there has been little attention to whether and how moral values differ from core values (e.g., Schwartz) or political values. As a result, it is unclear whether moral values are qualitatively different from other values and thus have outsized effects on outcomes such as affective polarization. In this paper, we argue that moral values are distinct from other values in that they focus on cooperation rather than self-oriented goals. Across two studies, we show that cooperative values tend to be more moralized than self-oriented values. Values derived from moral foundations theory, which have a cooperative basis, are consistently highly moralized – particularly the individualizing foundations. Some explicitly political values tend to be highly moralized when the values are cooperative (e.g., moral traditionalism) and less so when not (e.g., individualism). There is also considerable variation within the Schwartz typology, with cooperative values (e.g., benevolence) being highly moralized while self-oriented values (e.g., hedonism) are much less moralized. Finally, we test whether disagreement over highly moralized values (vs. less moralized values) has stronger effects on outcomes such as social distance and hostility. Overall, our findings suggest that cooperative values are more highly moralized than self-oriented values, which leads to greater hostility toward those who don’t share one’s values.