Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Descriptive Representation in an Era of Polarization

Sat, September 17, 3:30 to 4:00pm, TBA

Abstract

The literature on descriptive representation finds that voters generally evaluate representatives who share their race or gender more positively. A largely separate literature on polarization has found that Democratic and Republican voters have increasingly divergent attitudes about both race and gender, as well as representation. In this paper, I build on both literatures to argue that the effect of representatives’ ascriptive race and gender identities on constituents’ evaluations of them varies now more by party rather than by constituents’ own ascriptive identities, as it once did. Using CCES data from 2008 to 2020 and a difference-in-differences design, I find that across the years, Democratic respondents of all races and genders have increasingly approved more highly of their Members of Congress (MCs) when they are women or people of color, whereas Republicans’ approval has remained unrelated to MC identity. Moreover, while constituents from both parties use ideology to evaluate people in office, among Democrats, representatives’ ascriptive identities act as a partial substitute for ideological representation, meaning Democrats give more ideological “leeway” to MCs from historically underrepresented groups. An asymmetry in the ways the parties have polarized has altered classic patterns in how constituents evaluate their representatives.

Author