Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

“Canceled”: The Democratic Consequences of Perceived Censorship

Sat, September 17, 3:30 to 4:00pm, TBA

Abstract

In recent years, there has been a growing concern, especially for conservatives, about the so-called “cancel culture” and the “political censorship” on social media platforms in the United States. On the other hand, liberals also perceive some long-standing bans on LGBTQ materials, as well as the recent bans on the Critical Race Theory in schools as forms of political censorship on liberal views. Whether the “cancel culture”, content removal practices on Facebook or Twitter, or bans on Critical Race Theory are equivalent to censorship is highly contested along party lines. Nevertheless, the fact that a large portion of the population in a democracy believes their political views are censored is alarming and can lead to critical and potentially detrimental consequences to democracy.

Drawing on a wide range of psychological, economic, and communicative theories, I argue that perceived censorship is detrimental to democracy in three ways. First, perceived censorship reinforces people’s partisan identifications and ideologies by triggering psychological reactance. The ideological polarization further induces negative affect towards the other side of the political spectrum and exacerbates the already severe affective polarization problem in the United States. Second, perceived censorship provokes fear for the reputational cost of political expression and reduces the willingness to engage in political discussion with people with different political views. Third, perceived censorship, if implemented by government institutions, reduces citizens’ trust in democratic institutions. The author tests the hypotheses with a nationally representative experiment.

This study constitutes one of the first studies that examine the effect of perceived political censorship in a democracy. The widely perceived political censorship by other authorities in society, such as social media companies and powerful political groups with opposing political views, poses a severe threat to political discussion and deliberation in the United States. The findings have important implications for democracy in the United States amid growing controversies of alleged political censorship on social media and in society.

Author