Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Development and Drivers of Solidary Attitudes during the COVID Pandemic

Sat, September 17, 3:30 to 4:00pm, TBA

Abstract

Solidarity has become the key concept for coping with the Covid-19 pandemic and its effects on all sectors of state, economy, and society. Since the onset of the pandemic, solidarity constituted a central principle that was heavily invoked by governments and was considered to be a pivotal condition for the success of mitigating measures. This appeal to solidarity is also often linked to the call for citizens to abide by, share and accept the decisions made in the crisis management of the government. Thus, on one hand side, solidarity as claim takes on the character of an instruction for action and a practical guideline within the governments’ concept for crisis responses, on the other hand side, solidarity is the main principle used to legitimize government policies with the aim to keep societal cohesion.

In the first months of the pandemic in 2020, there could be observed a high degree of solidarity in most of the countries. Given the high practical relevance of citizens’ solidarity in the Covid-19 pandemic, the question is, however, if this solidarity persisted over time and how it developed in the course of 2020 and 2021. Already in summer 2020, citizens in several countries protested against, in their perspective, overly severe government measures. These protests continued in 2021 and even took a violent character (see Germany, Netherlands, France). This creates the impression of an evolving desolidarization the longer the pandemic endures.

This paper is interested to shed light on the microfoundations of solidarity during one of the most prominent global threats since World War II, its dynamics and the factors that account for changes or persistence of solidary attitude over time. The study has three aims: Firstly, it presents descriptive findings on the development of solidarity in Germany. Germany is one of the cases that is considered to have performed in a successful way during the early stage of the pandemic while at the same time the country is facing anti-Covid-19-measures protests since August 2020 and with increasing intensity in 2021. Thus, the question is: Do citizens display a ‘solidarity fatigue’ and has this led to broad desolidarization in the course of the pandemic? Or is it only a minor part of the citizens who back out from solidarity? Secondly, we aim to detect factors that influence the persistence of solidarity or desolidarization within the individual as the pandemic evolves. We test for social trust, trust into the government, risk awareness, and general satisfaction with democracy. Thirdly, we are investigating the evolution of solidarity attitudes and the evolving motivations and influencing factors over time by looking into online discourses related to solidarity behaviour and measures. Which themes or events are drivers for positive or negative attitudes towards solidarity and in which direction do these attitudes change?

For this study, we use a multi-method approach. The data base of the first two steps relies on a longitudinal panel survey that we conducted in November/December 2020 (2250 respondents), March/April 2021 (1670 respondents) and July/August (1370 respondents). We will run regression models to capture the change within the individual using panel data methods and identify the exact causal mechanisms influencing solidary behaviour and attitudes towards solidarity. For the third step of our analysis, we use an archive of Twitter data that includes a corpus of approximately 2 bn tweets in the period 01/2020 – 12/2021 and related online news media that is referenced as part of solidarity debates. Analysis will exploit methods from time series analysis and natural language processing, specifically aspect-based sentiment classification and named entity linking, to enable quantitative and qualitative analysis of opinions over time and their dependencies with societal events. Different to other studies, both sources of data offer a much more complete and fine-grained picture of the development of solidarity during the pandemic as we present a long-term perspective on citizens’ solidary (or not) attitudes complemented by the discursive dimension which reveals real time citizens’ opinions during intense anti-Covid-measures activities and their underlying dynamics over time.

This paper contributes to the ongoing debate on how to mitigate and cope with such crisis as the Covid-19 pandemic. There is a general consensus within policy makers as well as scholars that solidarity is a key element for crisis response. There still is a lack of understanding, however, about the degree of solidarity, the motives that drive solidarity and possible factors that might lead to desolidarization such as ‘pandemic fatigue’ and/or discontent with government’s crisis management. Our study presents so far rare findings revealing long-term developments on a key concept that will also have relevance for future crisis management.

Authors