Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

World Cultural Linkages as a Predictor of Cross-National Variance in Migrant Access to Rights

Mon, August 18, 4:30 to 5:30pm, TBA

Abstract

There is substantial cross-national variation in the degree to which rights enjoyed by the native citizenry are conferred upon foreign nationals. Furthermore, non-nationals rarely fully enjoy equal rights unless they naturalize. Despite such variance in accessibility to the legal institution of citizenship, extant studies on the determinants of such variation are fragmented, revealing contradictory findings. Comparative studies are largely qualitative and geographically limited to Western liberal democracies, making generalizable claims difficult; there has also been limited theorization on the impact of international exogenous pressures on state citizenship and nationality laws. Using the 2001 Citizenship Laws of the World dataset to obtain data on the minimum residency length requirements for naturalization as a proxy measure for migrant accessibility to rights, this cross-national study uses OLS regression to compare the explanatory power of world culture variables against domestic economic, political, and demographic variables commonly used in studies on the determinants of citizenship laws. Results show that membership in international non-governmental organizations (INGOs) best predicts cross-national variance in the minimum residency length requirements for naturalization, thereby suggesting that extensive linkages with INGOs and the resulting diffusion of world cultural scripts on human rights into the domestic society and polity influence a state’s willingness to confer to migrants the ultimate means to legal membership and access to rights. (A version of this paper was initially submitted and accepted to the 2013 ASA Annual Meeting; however, the author was unable to attend, and the paper was never presented at the meeting.)

Author