Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Contested Identities, Contested Rights: Education, Religion, and the Politics of Governance

Sun, August 17, 10:30am to 12:10pm, TBA

Abstract

Extensive research has documented the role of the school in societal rationalization (e.g. Drori et al. 2003, 2006; Fuller and Robinson 1992; Meyer 1977, 2005; Bourdieu 1994). This literature broadly argues that increasingly standardized education systems produce citizen-subjects who can effectively function in a rationalized modern society and economy. However, private education constitutes a space that potentially disrupts this rationalized process, such as an increasingly deregulated home-schooling movement or legal exemption from secondary education for the Amish. This paper focuses on a previously unanalyzed case study of such disruption: a loose network of male-only Hasidic schools in New York which, circumventing state regulations, provide predominantly religious instruction and little to no secular education such as math, English, or history. I collect and analyze legitimizing discourses used by Hasidic activists, educators, local politicians, and administrative officials to explain how a rationalized state accommodates conflicting notions of education and citizenship. Moving beyond standard explanations of local political maneuvering, I argue that these discourses reveal a fundamental concept of *legitimate non-rationalized citizenship,* which groups like the Hasidim mobilize to claim rights to societal resources and state support. Moreover, the very political and state actors who produce and enforce the rationalized governance of education support Hasidic communities' ability to circumvent regulations and oversight. In this way, alternative notions of citizen-subjects are formed not only through the mobilized efforts of ethno-religious enclaves, but through the very democratic principles underlying the rationalized state.

Author