Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Searching for "Whosoever Ministries": Examining Black Gay Men's Church-Going Decisions

Sat, August 16, 4:30 to 6:10pm, TBA

Abstract

Historically, churches in the Black community have provided social support and served as centers of Black identity socialization. However, many churches have also generated anti-gay messages within the community. As such, Black gay men (BGM) experience an inordinate amount of stigma in churches, despite being highly involved in religious activities. Stigma often leads to identity conflict between their Black, gay, and religious identities, which can have consequences for their mental and physical health. I examined semi-structured interviews and online surveys from 31 self-identified BGM between 23 to 57 years old, and 26 hours of ethnographic observation at three churches participants attended to understand the strategies BGM use to reduce conflict between their Black, gay, and religious identities. I used Goffman’s theory of stigma management as a theoretical framework. Findings show that BGM employed both stigma deflection and normalization strategies to reduce conflicts. BGM attempted to deflect the stigma of homosexuality by remaining members of “regular,” predominantly heterosexual Black churches or demanding that Black gay-affirming churches adopt characteristics of “regular” churches. They also expressed a preference to either forgo church attendance or attend predominantly Black churches that were silent on homosexuality versus attending predominantly White, gay-affirming churches. An intersectional analysis of Black gay men’s stigma deflection strategies allows for an understanding of how multiple stigmatized identities influence religious choice and participation. This study contributes to our understanding of how people with intersectional identities and multiple stigmas manage identity conflict and make decisions around institutional participation.

Author