On Bauman’s Interpretation of Weber.

• In Event: 352 - Theory Section Roundtables (one-hour)
  In Refereed Roundtable: Table 03. Classic Theorists: Marx, Weber, Bourdieu

Abstract

On Bauman’s Interpretation of Weber
Abstract

This article provides a re-assessment of Bauman’s interpretation of Weber. Bauman has consistently praised Weber for his ability to understand the modern condition, and Bauman considers him as a sociologist of the modern age, but also as an academic outsider. Weber could therefore understand better than other scholars that “lighter” (rather than “heavy”) modalities of the capitalist order are conceivable. “Lighter capitalism” is however a trait of Bauman’s conception of post modernity (which this article briefly considers), rather than of modernity. Weber has also grasped, according to Bauman, the inconclusiveness of the rationalization process and called attention to a future, which is different from that prefigured by the modernity project. Bauman is accordingly not entirely consistent in considering Weber a sociologist of modernity. It has also been argued here that the scope of Du Gay’s critique of Bauman’s interpretation of Weber should be extended, as there are for Weber several aspects of modern society that are not compatible with instrumental rationality. In particular, Weber has dwelt on value-rational aspects of modernity - such as the persistence of the values of solidarity and honour in the market, in the workers’ unions, and in the bourgeoisie as a status group - which Bauman has neglected to consider.

Author

• Sandro Segre, University of Genoa