Search
Program Calendar
Browse By Day
Browse By Time
Browse By Person
Browse By Session Type
Browse By Topic
Personal Schedule
Sign In
Deadlines
Policies
Updating Your Submission
Requesting AV
Presentation Tips
Request a Visa Letter
FAQs
X (Twitter)
Search Tips
Annual Meeting App
About Annual Meeting
Qualitative Comparative Analysis (QCA) has been increasingly used in recent years due to its purported construction of a middle path between case-oriented and variable-oriented methods. Despite its popularity, the method has been criticized for not distinguishing random from real patterns in data, rendering its usefulness questionable. Stanley Lieberson (2004), in illustrating this criticism, suggests a straightforward technique to test whether QCA will return a configuration when given random data. We adapt this technique to determine the probability of any given QCA result is due to random chance, which can be used as a robustness assessment for QCA with an interpretation similar to a p-value. Using repeated applications of QCA to randomly-generated data, we first show that generally, the tendency for QCA to return spurious results is greatly attenuated by using reasonable consistency score and configurational n thresholds; however, this varies greatly according to the basic structure of the data, suggesting the need for further robustness assessments. Second, we apply a case-by-case application of this technique to data predicting
the occurrence of Tea Party rallies in Florida. This method, which we coin the Lieberson Robustness Assessment for QCA (LaQCA), can provide researchers with case-by-case recommendations for consistency score and configurational n thresholds, while taking into account the structure of the data.