Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

The Importance of Historical Methods for Building Theories of Urban Environmental Inequality

Mon, August 22, 2:30 to 4:10pm, TBA

Abstract

Despite the accumulation of a large body of research, testable theories of the development of environmental inequality are still lacking. Existing explanations cannot explain contradictory findings such as the presence of environmentally burdened, predominantly white communities. In this paper, I argue that unanswered questions and the lack of theory stem from the deficiencies of both quantitative empirical findings and qualitative historical case studies as material to build theory. Quantitative spatial statistical studies present snapshots of proximity or exposure to hazard that are decontextualized, ahistorical, oversimplify intersectional social identities such as race/ethnicity and social class, and are often implicitly assumed to be generalizable to the entire U.S. Qualitative case studies offer rich contextual data, but the extent to which they are generalizeable beyond the case is unknown. In this paper, I use material from my recent historical work tracing the development of environmental inequality in the Philadelphia area to demonstrate the efficacy of historical methods (path-dependence and causal process tracing) for creating testable theories of environmental inequality.

Author