Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

How Intraparty Struggles Internationalized the New Deal: Liberals, Trumanites, and the Marshall Plan 1945-48

Sun, August 12, 12:30 to 2:10pm, Philadelphia Marriott Downtown, Floor: Level 4, 409

Abstract

America’s large-scale aid program to postwar Europe, the Marshall Plan (1948-1952), has received little attention in historical sociology. Typically explained by historians as an effect of a bipartisan embrace of liberal internationalism, we argue this overlooks how a reorganization of power positions within the Democratic Party between 1945 and 1948 made bipartisan support of the Marshall Plan possible—which, in turn, facilitated the consolidation of a broadly liberal internationalist stance among political elites, despite the declining power of liberals. We thus focus on struggles within the Democratic Party between labor-friendly, anti-communist, FDR-associated New Dealers (the “liberals”) and labor-skeptical, anti-Soviet, Midwestern Democrats loyal to President Truman (the “Trumanites”) between 1945 and 1948. We show how, after FDR’s death, the Trumanites displaced New Dealers from the White House—and how, in response, a faction of New Dealers broke with Democratic “progressives,” defining themselves as explicitly anti-communist “liberals” in order to stay in the political game. From early 1947 the liberals made use of ties to New Deal agencies, the continuation of which was enabled by their anti-communist stance, to inform plans for a large-scale foreign aid program—which was then sold to Congress as an anti-communist policy. The result was a program that created a New Deal-type settlement that both Trumanites and Congressional conservatives opposed in principle, but supported in practice. We highlight the implications of our argument for contemporary U.S. foreign policy, and specifically the potential of an approach that places intraparty struggles central.

Author