Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Embodied Authority: The Incongruence of Women's Bodies and Perceived Ability to Lead

Tue, August 14, 12:30 to 2:10pm, Philadelphia Marriott Downtown, Floor: Level 4, Franklin Hall 4

Abstract

Despite women graduating from Baptist seminaries in almost equal numbers as men, today women still only represent only 5% of lead pastor positions in the Cooperative Baptist Fellowship (CBF), a phenomenon across religious denominations referred to as the “stained glass ceiling” (e.g. Purvis, 1997). This study examines the taken-for-granted gendered organizational processes within CBF-affiliated congregations that contribute to and reinforce barriers faced by women pastors despite organizational and theological goals of gender equality. By applying the theoretical lens of gendered organizations (Acker 1990) and the methodological approach of critical ethnography, this research explores congregants’ expectations and pastors’ experiences to address the following questions: (1) When people are committed to gender equality, what gets in their way of achieving it? (2) What organizational processes contribute to inequitable outcomes between men and women leaders within CBF congregations? (3) Why does dissonance persist between organizational actors’ good intentions of equality and sexist outcomes? In an effort to partly answer these questions, this presentation draws on interview data to illustrate how congregants perceive women’s bodies and how these perceptions function as barriers to women effectively maintaining positions of authority in the church. Specifically, it shows how women pastors are simultaneously expected to conceal and accentuate their femininity and are sexualized by male congregants as they engage in leadership tasks. Moreover, this presentation demonstrates how gendered congregational perceptions related to the body create impossible and additional expectations for women pastors that are not applied in the evaluation of male pastors’ performance thus resulting in inequitable outcomes between men and women pastors. Finally, these results highlight how women maneuver through these organizational barriers in ways that are perhaps necessary to succeed but ultimately reinforce the inequitable gender structure of these congregations.

Author