Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

Bargaining around Alternative Sanctions? Innovative Approach in Studying Case Outcomes

Thu, Nov 20, 12:30 to 1:50pm, Marriott, Salon 12, Lower B2 Level

Abstract

Most extant studies on plea bargaining focused on incarceration outcomes. However, in practice both prosecution and defense spend considerable effort in bargaining around outcomes that do not involve incarceration, i.e. alternative sanctions. Little knowledge on this process has been accumulated given the shortage of empirical studies. Studies on incarceration outcomes focus on the division between “in” and “out”. This study intends to fill the research gap by further investigating the patterns within the “out” group. For this purpose this study introduces an innovative methodology—latent class analysis—into sentencing studies. This method allows identification of unobserved “classes” based on the whole sentence bundle defendants received, rather than studying each type of sentence individually. In addition to identifying the classes, this statistical technique also estimates the posterior probability of each individual defendant’s class membership. The ultimate interest of this study is to understand how legal and extralegal variables affect the likelihood of class membership, and how the findings reflect prosecution and sentencing practice.

Author