Individual Submission Summary
Share...

Direct link:

On the Right of the Accused to Examine Witnesses According to Article 6(3)(d) of the European Convention on Human Rights (ECHR)

Thu, Nov 20, 6:00 to 8:00pm, Marriott, Golden Gate, B2 Level

Abstract

In criminal proceedings the right of the accused to examine or have examined witnesses against him – as granted by the ECHR – is key. Reporting on this crucial defendant’s right, two aspects shall be addressed.
Firstly, the scope of the right to examine the witness has to be determined with due regard to what extent and in which manner the confrontation with the witnesses of the prosecution is to take place: Does Article 6(3) (d) of the ECHR provide for an equally direct and personal confrontation as the Amendment VI to the United States Constitution?
Secondly, restrictions to the right to confrontation in cases of vulnerable witnesses or wit-nesses at risk come into focus. One such limit is to separate the accused and the “witness in danger” physically while taking the oral evidence simultaneously by videoconference. This approach gives rise to further volatilisation of the fundamental-rights guarantee to confron-tation with inculpatory evidence, e. g. the mutilating effects of optical shielding or acoustic baffle as well as the potential curtailments in consequence of judges questioning the witness under protection thereby restrain the defendant’s right to confrontation.

Author